Well imo they are. I never liked SM64 or Sunshine, but I loved Wind Waker and TP. I've never played any MP, so I don't know why I said that :/

You said "TP and MP3 > SMG. I don't even like Mario anymore." Its probably your tastes but in the future, please don't say one game is better than another game you haven't played.

SMG! though I haven’t played TOS Wii but there is nothing compared to SMG it is fun it is good it is challenging (later on) and it is Mario!oh and it is fun!

Depends what your into. Platforming or RPG's it's really depending on the person to interpret which game is better.

thanks for all the advice on selecting a game, i just bought tales of symphonia :dotnw and super mario galaxy for the wii, also got resident evil 4 wii edition. and for my ps3 i got tomb raider:underworld. if any of my ps3 games that i own, if someone wants to play them with me, add me to your friendlist. thanks again everyone for your help. :)

You did the right thing by buying both of them. They should keep you busy until well into the new year. Remember there are 120 stars to get in SMG :) and you only need 60 to beat the game BUT you'll want to get all of them since its so incredibly fun.

Can't ya just get both haha. I mean I'd have to recommend SMG over ToS: DotNW but I need more people to buy ToS so I get a 3rd one haha.

Sorry that's based on self-interest. Go with SMG and buy ToS later. SMG is an outstanding platformer and the best since SM64 and ToS is an average but fun and compelling RPG. Choice is easy but just promise me you'll get Tales eventually.

You are my hero buddy.  Now that'd doing the world justice haha.  Good choices.

Every Wii owner needs Mario Galaxy.

Glad to see you're a gamer ater my own heart, though XD

@zucas, thanks . just doing my part in supporting the best games. :)