@OP:
surely, as others have said, they can look for the serial number, if you were on PSN they might even have your MAC adress too...perhaps they could blacklist it or w/e, but going around to the dudes place and kicking ass is not a great idea. they'd just come back with chainsaws, then you'll retalliate with rocket launchers, an almost endless cycle until you start flinging nukes around at eachother.
Just call the cops and/or Sony.
Proud Sony Rear Admiral