Pokemon Red countless times!

Ive finished Ocarina of Time maybe 5-6 times.

Edit - Incandescence reminded me! Pokemons Red is #1 I dont even remeber how many times Ive played through that game so its #1

The Ocarina of Time - 3 times.

There are so many old games that I'd love to replay, but there are so many games I own that I haven't finished, some of which I haven't even started! That combined with all the new games coming out means that I'm not likely to replay any older games anytime soon.

RE4 ive beaten it around 40 times,if you count the wii version over 50 times

Pokemon diamond I go to the league all the time.

I've beaten Uncharted 5 times.

Beat Normal and hard when it came out.
And last week after trophies were patched I beat normal, hard and crushing.........

PS : I've beaten MGS4 4 times so far ( normal, Boss Hard, normal having fun with my well earned stealth item , Big Boss Hard), if they ever patch trophies I could see myself beating it 10+ times lol...........

Once i finish a game i usually shelf it..... too many other games to play.

However I guess Metroid would be the game I beat the most times, if only to show everyone how "cool" the ending is...

although most of those wasn't starting from the beginning again....

what do you get out of beating the same game over and over again?

Pokemon Silver.

Seriously if MGS4 ever gets Trophies support and assuming the trophies become the current Emblems you will need something like clearing the game 10 times to get the platinum trophy.....

Donkey Kong 64 and Banjo Tooie-beated both 4 times

I rarely replay games, though I will be am replaying Assassin's Creed for the 3rd time now. Uncharted (still playing) and Ratchet are the only other games I have replayed