i dont want none of them but unleashed just sounds retarded i mean werehog? what the hell were they thinking. and like naz said the game looks like a hold right to win when your not the werehog.

i want both

Black Knight

Black knight

I'm holding out for Sonic 4.

fixed

I hope Bioware does a great job in this game.

Black Knight look far better than unleashed

Unleashed and Black Knight sound like they're taking the places of 06 and Secret Rings respectively. In that case, my money is on Black Knight.

Secret Rings was treated as the red headed stepchild compared to 06 and came out of nowhere, only to be largely considered a much better game and outsold both versions of Sonic 06. I think Unleashed is going to be a lot better than 06 but Black Knight being a sequel to Secret Rings already has a leg up since that team inherently created a better Sonic game.

Interesting deduction of mine, though, revolves aroudn the recent rating of a multiplat Sonic game on the OFLC simply titled "Sonic the Hedgehog." Sonic is already on the VC, the Matser System version of StH is literally called "Sonic the Hedgehog on the Master System" or something like that. So I think Sega might be porting Sonic 06 to Wii.

This depends on the fanbase your talking about. I myself loved Sonic 06 gameplay for the most part, but horrible loading times and a crappy plot line with lots of talking ruined it. I rented the game and while I enjoyed about 20-minutes of playing it their was 2-hours of complete crap needed to play that 20-minutes.

However I found Secret Rings to be far worse. I hate rail games and Sonic Secret Rings was no excemption I hated the game so bad that I returned it early and only played some half an hour or so of it. I hate being thrust forward at incredible rates of speed just to die running head long into an enemy.

As for me possibly buying unleashed over Black Knight. I want a Sonic game I love Sonic and I know their are platforming with WereHog. I still hate the idea of rails which seems to be the main part of Sonic Unleashed's Sonic gameplay but I will rent the game and see just how good it is.

All in all I'm dissapointed with both games, I want Sonic Adventure 3 to come out, the last Sonic game I remotley liked was Shadow:TheHedgehog and that wasn't the greatest Sonic game either!