i didnt think it will fall below it,but thats what a couple of 8's do

I noticed this earlier today but didn't say anything because I didn't deem it news worthy. SMG is just a better game period. (And I am a huge GTA fan)

This thread is gonna go hate-bomb soon, so before that happens, let me say, in my review, I thought SMG was as good or slightly better than GTAIV, and that OOT was significantly better. I stand by that.

^well SMG is really revolutionary,i just got 120 stars with mario,now im starting with luigi,and this def is my fav game ever

tht is also what GR stands by,i will have to play OoT again to see if it deserves top spot as i was to young when i first played it and i dont really remember how good it was

Really SMG is the best game this generation until now.

if SMG 2 omes out or if the next zelda is as revolutionary as OoT then they might dethrone SMG,but we will also see if GTA4 will fight back

Yay, one game has more numbers than another game.

Pretty sad all of a writer's work in a review is boiled down to one number and then even further marginalized by being lumped in with a bigger number ensuring that no one will actually read what they wrote. Well, I guess it makes the Nintendo fanboys stop frothing at the mouth for a while, so I guess it serves some purpose. Kinda like a fresh shipment of sedatives to the nuthouse.

I give this thread a 9.1.

^do you always rate threads?

oh no, here we go again, personally i couldnt give a f**k