its always seemed like mario kart games score quite low for how good they are. every generation the mario kart game is one of the best multiplayer games available hands down. yet they never get great scores.
at first i felt the reviews were justified because of the no co-op grand prix. but then i realized that the co-op is better than ever before and its in the vs. section. the only minor negative is you can't actually do the cups themselves in co-op so you can't go through the game and set new records for the cups in two player mode. but with all the new options they give you for co-op racing the changes far outweigh that one negative.
i'd say this is how it breaks down:
positives- expanded co-op racing, online, bikes added, tricks, 16 old school tracks, old battle arenas, and all the sweet new features of time trialing, added difficulty, greater differences between characters, and it's ridiculously fun!
negatives- new battle arenas are specifically made for lots of people online so with a few less than 12 people they are far too big, teams-only battle (just no point in only including that), no special items (my biggest complaint against the game cuz i thought that was the best addition of Double Dash), and the red shell is far improved to the point where you almost can't dodge it which i think is an effort on nintendo's part to appeal more to the non-gamers but it takes away a crucial element available to skilled racers (i mean now red shells are harder to block by putting an object behind you because they seem to come in from the side, you can't lose them on quick abrupt turns, and they will actually slow down and come to a stop for you as well as wait for you if you hit a jump or something to be able to hit you).
the in-betweens (things i'm not sure on or are decent but not great or bad)- the change in the drift speed boost, the items, the courses.
to explain the in-betweens i'd say i kinda like the new drifting and no snaking but at the same time that just seems like another nintendo attempt to take away the skill of the game and let non-gamers compete which isn't a good thing. also the items are decent, i like some new ones, but i think the pow is pretty dumb, overall the items are fine but not great, but the lack of specials is a huge negative as stated earlier. and the courses, well so far i haven't decided if they are that great, they are at least pretty good, but i don't know if nintendo really made some amazing new courses for us in this one.
bottom line: a few negatives, lots of great new things added, and a few things either changed or weren't changed that i think are decent but don't necesarily make the game any better that previous MK's. but the game is soooooooo fun like all the mario karts so for me it is definitely AAA.
end of '08 predictions: wii - 43 million, 360 - 25 million, ps3 - 20 million
Games I've beat recently: Super Mario Galaxy, Knights of the Old Republic, Shadow of the Collossus
Proud owner of wii, gamecube, xbox, ps2, dreamcast, n64, snes, genesis, 3DO, nes, atari, intellivision, unisonic tournament 2000, and gameboy