You have Oblivion in there twice.
Also, I believe BioShock is an FPS. 9.4 on IGN, 95 on metacritic. 9.2 on gamestats. That would put it in either second or first place.

I think you should get rid of the 'sandbox' section and integrate those games into the other sections. You've already got Oblivion as RPG, I think GTA4 would be a TPS, so would Saint's Row 2.
Assassin's Creed should go in Action.

I think your title should be IGN's Best game guide.

i think you should make a table of contents. lets say you wanna go to FPS games.... you click on the FPS Game titles which is a link tot he first post for the FPS games secrtion.

I think you probably need to add Motorstorm Pacific Rift, but I assume that means you have to remove MotorStorm from the top of the list? and put PR further down because I think it only got 8.3 from IGN

Also, I think putting Bioshock ahead of CoD 4 is going to be a contentious decision...

@ machina, because CoD 4 is heralded as one of the best games ever... my personal preference would be for CoD, but it does not really matter

Fallout 3 is a sandbox game, I believe. 9.4 on IGN, 90 on metacritic. That is likely to change, though.

This guide might be very useful if I ever get a ps3.

Devil May Cry 4 actually got an 8.7 from IGN US, the 9 was from IGN UK I think.
Also, Valkyria Chronicles has a 9/10 on IGN. Not sure where it would go, though- Games You Might Have Missed?

i think this is a mint thread! well done!