By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - PAL Charts week 18 (2008) gta 4 VS gta 4

koffieboon on 09 May 2008
BKK2 said:
koffieboon said:
BKK2: FishyJoe just posted this article about WiiFit selling 338k so far in the UK.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1941532/Wii-fit-on-course-to-become-best-selling-exercise-trend-of-all-time.html

Combined with the 58% drop in WiiFit sales in the second week that puts WiiFit first week sales at 238k with a margin of error of about 2k. Maybe this info can be useful for your highest first week sales list you have for the UK.

 Great minds think alike :)


It seems that way!

And we can start round 2 of the GTA IV fight, because Dutch charts for week 19 are up (I know they should come in a new thread, but those are normally made by someone else). GTA IV on PS3 and 360 switched places in The Netherlands for week 19, is it the start of a clean sweep for the PS3 version of the game this week? Probably not, but at least they gained 1 additional country in PS3's favour.

1 2 2 GRAND THEFT AUTO 4 (PS3) TAKE 2 INTERACTIVE  

2 1 2 GRAND THEFT AUTO 4 (X-BOX 360) TAKE 2 INTERACTIVE  

3 3 2 WII FIT (Wii) NINTENDO  

4 7 12 BRAIN TRAINING (Nintendo DS) NINTENDO  

5 6 21 MARIO & SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES (Wii) SEGA  

6 4 5 MARIO KART (Wii) NINTENDO

7 5 12 MARIO & SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES (Nintendo DS) SEGA

8 10 12 MORE BRAIN TRAINING (Nintendo DS) NINTENDO

9 8 4 MY WORD COACH/VERBETER JE WOORDENSCHAT (Nintendo DS) UBISOFT

10 RE 15 MARIO PARTY 8 (Wii) NINTENDO

 

 

 



Around the Network
BKK2 on 09 May 2008

Interesting, sales are probably very close in Netherlands, or maybe there was supply problems as in Sweden. I can't see PS3 outselling 360 version in UK next week anyway. The ones where we might see changes will be Australia, New Zealand, and Sweden. It's a shame we don't get individual format charts for Denmark, Ireland, Finland, or Norway, would be interesting to see how it went in those countries.



koffieboon on 09 May 2008
BKK2 said:
Interesting, sales are probably very close in Netherlands, or maybe there was supply problems as in Sweden. I can't see PS3 outselling 360 version in UK next week anyway. The interesting ones where we might see changes will be Australia, New Zealand, and Sweden. It's a shame we don't get individual format charts for Denmark, Ireland, Finland, or Norway, would be interesting to see how it went in those countries.

UK is definitely the one I'm most interested in for next week, not only the split between the different consoles but also how much sales will drop. Although it had a record breaking opening it still sold out, so first week sales could even have been higher. Normally I would have expected a drop similar in size as Halo 3, so around 80%, but could this one sell another 300-400k next week?



BKK2 on 09 May 2008

Yes, I'm very interested in seeing the % drop in the UK too. I think 300k - 400k across both platforms is quite possible. PS3 attach rate was so high first week that I'd expect the split to be more than 55/45 next week. Maybe 57/43, or 200k/150k. That's my guess anyway.



koffieboon on 09 May 2008

I also expect the gap in the UK between the 2 versions to be bigger next week (of course talking in percentages and not absolute numbers). But for the whole of Europe PS3 might actually be further ahead because UK sales will probably make up a smaller part of European sales next week.



Around the Network
BKK2 on 11 May 2008

Norway

Topp 20 Konsoll

01 NE Grand Theft Auto IV (PS3 360)
02 02 Wii Fit (Wii)
03 01 Mario Kart Wii (Wii)
04 03 Guitar Hero 3: Legends of Rock (PS2 PS3 360 Wii)
05 04 UEFA Euro 2008 (PS3 360 PS2 PC PSP)
06 10 FIFA 08 (PS2 PS3 360 Wii)
07 06 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (PC PS3 360)
08 05 Gran Turismo 5 Prologue (PS3)
09 11 Army of Two (PS3 360)
10 NE Singstar Summer Party (PS2)
11 12 Time Crisis 4 (PS3)
12 07 Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas 2 (PC PS3 360)
13 09 MX vs. ATV: Untamed (PS2 PS3 PSP 360 Wii DS)
14 08 Buzz Junior: Dino Den (PS2)
15 16 Assassin's Creed (360 PS3 PC)
16 13 Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)
17 14 Burnout Paradise (PS3 360)
18 17 Need For Speed: ProStreet (PC PS2 PS3 360 Wii PSP DS)
19 RE Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga (PS3 360 Wii DS)
20 15 Viking: Battle For Asgard 3(60 PS3)

Topp 10 Handholdt

01 01 New Super Mario Bros. (DS)
02 05 Nintendogs (DS)
03 04 Pokémon Diamond/Pearl (DS)
04 02 Mario Kart DS (DS)
05 03 Super Mario 64 DS (DS)
06 06 Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games (DS)
07 07 God of War: Chains of Olympus (PSP)
08 RE FIFA 08 (DS PSP)
09 NE Zoo Tycoon 2 DS (DS)
10 RE Ratchet & Clank: Size Matters (PSP)

Topp 10 pc

01 02 The Sims 2: Fritid
02 01 Assassin's Creed
03 07 Football Manager 2008
04 06 Josefine Skolehjelp: Matterallyet
05 05 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
06 10 The Sims 2: Bon Voyage
07 08 The Sims 2
08 04 Josefine Skolehjelp: Bokstavjungelen
09 03 Command & Conquer 3: Kane's Wrath
10 RE Josefine Skolehjelp: Reisen til kroppen



lombard2578 on 12 May 2008

Thanks BKK2 for Norway.
Links for handhelds and pc:

http://www.vg.no/spill/topp10handholdt.hbs?liste=3&uke=20&aar=2008
http://www.vg.no/spill/topp10pc.hbs?liste=1&uke=20&aar=2008

Why not to give the platforms, but in this case, for the consoles top, we must delete psp, ds, and pc.



lombard2578 on 13 May 2008

Italy charts:

http://www.forumeye.it/invision/index.php?showtopic=434850&st=60

Italia
Week 18 - 28 Aprile 04 Maggio

01 - GTA 4 PS3 100
02 - GTA 4 360 58,77
03 - Wii Fit WII 21,18
04 - Mario Kart WII 6,33
05 - Cooking Mama 2 DS 4,37
06 - GT 5 Prologue PS3 3,43
07 - Mario & Sonic Ai Giochi Olimpici DS 3,26
08 - UEFA Euro 2008 PS2 2,93
09 - Brain Training DS 2,90
10 - PES 2008 PSP 2,84
11 - GTA San Andreas Platinum PS2 2,54
12 - PES 2008 PS2 2,49
13 - New Super Mario Bros DS 2,26
14 - Mario Kart DS 2,21
15 - Cooking Mama DS 2,15


Fonte: GFK


Note: per GTA sono stati sommati anche le limited (altrimenti sarebbero stati in 4° e 5° posizione da soli) e finalmente PES per PS2 esce dalla Top 10 dopo esserci rimasta ininterrottamente dalla sua uscita


Numbers of prosugno:

01 - GTA 4 (PS3) [87.200] [shipped 100.000]
02 - GTA 4 (360 ) [51.300] [shipped 60.000]
03 - Wii Fit (WII) [18.400]
04 - Mario Kart (WII) [5.550]
05 - Cooking Mama 2 (DS) [3.950]
06 - GT 5 Prologue (PS3) [3.050]
07 - Mario & Sonic Ai Giochi Olimpici (DS) [2.900]
08 - UEFA Euro 2008 (PS2) [2.700]
09 - Brain Training (DS) [2.600]
10 - Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 (PSP) [2.550]



Charts from Nielsen:

http://www.multiplayer.it/notizia.php?id=55725

 

    TOP 10 All Formats
  1. Grand Theft Auto IV (PS3)
  2. Grand Theft Auto IV (X360)
  3. Loki (PC)
  4. Wii Fit + Balance Board (Wii)
  5. Mario Kart Wii + Wii Wheel (Wii)
  6. Cooking Mama 2: Dinner With Friends (DS)
  7. Grand Theft Auto IV Special Edition (PS3)
  8. Grand Theft Auto IV (PS3)
  9. Grand Theft Auto IV Special Edition (X360)
  10. Hospital Tycoon (PC)
    Top 10 PC
  1. Loki
  2. Hospital Tycoon
  3. IF22
  4. The Sims 2 Kitchen and Bath Interior Design Stuff
  5. Assassin's Creed
  6. Age of Empires III The Asian Dynasties
  7. World of Warcraft game Card
  8. Eva Cash: Project D.I.R.T.
  9. Colin McRae DIRT
  10. Imperium Civitas Premium
    TOP 10 PS2
  1. UEFA Euro 2008
  2. Pro Evolution Soccer 2008
  3. FIFA 08
  4. Moto GP 07
  5. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas Platinum
  6. EyeToy Play 3
  7. Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi 3
  8. Naruto Uzumaki Chronicles 2
  9. FIFA 08
  10. God of War 2
    TOP 10 PS3
  1. Grand Theft Auto IV
  2. Grand Theft Auto IV Special Edition
  3. Grand Theft Auto IV
  4. Gran Turismo 5 Prologue
  5. Pro Evolution Soccer 2008
  6. UEFA Euro 2008
  7. Time Crisis 4
  8. Assassin's Creed
  9. Call of Duty 4
  10. FIFA 08
    TOP 10 Wii
  1. Wii Fit + Balance Board
  2. Mario Kart con Wii Wheel
  3. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
  4. Super Mario Galaxy
  5. Pro Evolution Soccer 2008
  6. Naruto Clash of Ninja Revolution
  7. Mario & Sonic alle Olimpiadi
  8. Wii Play
  9. Mario Kart con Wii Wheel
  10. FIFA 08
    TOP 10 Xbox 360
  1. Grand Theft Auto IV
  2. Grand Theft auto IV Special Edition
  3. Grand Theft Auto IV
  4. UEFA Euro 2008
  5. Assassin's Creed
  6. Call of Duty 4
  7. Pro Evolution Soccer 2008
  8. Iron Man
  9. Viking Battle for Asgard
  10. Bioshock
    TOP 10 DS
  1. Cooking Mama 2: Dinner with Friends
  2. Mario & Sonic alle Olimpiadi
  3. Brain Training del Dr. Kawashima
  4. New Super Mario Bros.
  5. Cooking Mama
  6. More Brain Training del Dr. Kawashima
  7. More Brain Training del Dr. Kawashima
  8. Mario Kart
  9. Pokémon Diamante
  10. Nintendogs Labrador
    TOP 10 PSP
  1. Pro Evolution Soccer 2008
  2. God of War: Chains of Olympus
  3. Ratchet & Clank: l'Altezza non Conta Platinum
  4. UEFA Euro 2008
  5. FIFA 08
  6. FIFA 08 Platinum
  7. Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Heroes
  8. The Simpsons
  9. Dragonball Z Shin Budokai Platinum
  10. Dragonball Z Shin Budokai 2
    Classifica Hardware:
  1. Wii
  2. Nintendo DS
  3. PSP
  4. PlayStation 3
  5. Xbox 360
  6. PlayStation 2

 



BKK2 on 13 May 2008
lombard2578 said:

Italy charts:

http://www.forumeye.it/invision/index.php?showtopic=434850&st=60

Italia
Week 18 - 28 Aprile 04 Maggio

01 - GTA 4 PS3 100
02 - GTA 4 360 58,77
03 - Wii Fit WII 21,18
04 - Mario Kart WII 6,33
05 - Cooking Mama 2 DS 4,37
06 - GT 5 Prologue PS3 3,43
07 - Mario & Sonic Ai Giochi Olimpici DS 3,26
08 - UEFA Euro 2008 PS2 2,93
09 - Brain Training DS 2,90
10 - PES 2008 PSP 2,84
11 - GTA San Andreas Platinum PS2 2,54
12 - PES 2008 PS2 2,49
13 - New Super Mario Bros DS 2,26
14 - Mario Kart DS 2,21
15 - Cooking Mama DS 2,15


Fonte: GFK


Note: per GTA sono stati sommati anche le limited (altrimenti sarebbero stati in 4° e 5° posizione da soli) e finalmente PES per PS2 esce dalla Top 10 dopo esserci rimasta ininterrottamente dalla sua uscita






 


 

Notes: GTA have been combined also limited (otherwise would have been in 4 th and 5 th position alone) and finally PES for PS2 comes out of the Top 10 after have remained continuously since its exit

01 - GTA 4 PS3 100
02 - GTA 4 360 58,77

That's in line with the initial shipment of 100k x PS3 & 60k x 360. 

 



kamil on 13 May 2008

For Italy we know that initial GTA shipmeants for PS3 and X360 were 100k and 60k respectivly and X360 were sold out. So it's possible that X360 version will be at 60k and thus PS3 at around 100k. They could have been another shipmeans (and apperently were for PS3) so real numbers may be even higher.