By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - The Joy-Con should've been the Wii U's controller instead of the GamePad

One of the Wii U's biggest mistakes was having the Wii Remote take a backseat to the Wii U GamePad. A bulky tablet screen controller that was supposed to enable "Revolutionary new ways to play", but ended up being a mostly useless battery hog that even Nintendo struggled to find a compelling use for.

I know a lot of the "Hardcore Gamer TM" crowd here have a pathological hatred of motion controls (and to be fair some of it is justified, some of it isn't), but in all honesty, the Joy-Con controllers of the Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2 really should've been the standard controllers for Wii U.

The Joy-Con are pretty much the logical evolution of the Wii Remote + Nunchuck setup. They keep all the good aspects of them (Motion Controls, free-hand movement, the ability to hold them single handed) but remove the biggest limitations (Lack of buttons, the short cord). Had the Wii U launched a little earlier with a different name and a controller more similar to the Joy-Con, it probably wouldn't have been the miserable failure it was. And if you hate "waggle", then the controllers have the standard layout of a traditional controller, so you could play games normally if you wanted.



Around the Network

Absolutely not. The Joycons are the Switch's biggest detriment out-of-the-box, with their dinky-ass buttons and flimsy sticks, but at least I see their purpose for use with that particular system. Switching between modes or handing someone a second controller for table-top play at least makes sense. The compromise of comfort and ergonomics for portability somewhat justifies their design with Switch.

For WiiU, their limits and design make no sense at all. And while they would not have jacked up the price as much as the Gamepad, the Joycons still ain't cheap. Nintendo would have been better off just including a motion-plus Wiimote & nunchuck setup for WiiU instead, which has a far better stick and buttons (not to mention a frickin D-pad), and let people rely on the pro controller for traditional play.

Last edited by archbrix - on 13 October 2026

The Wii U GamePad is more comfortable than a Switch with JoyCons.
It wouldn't have made sense to drop Wii Remote support when Wii U plays Wii games.
A home console that can play Wii games makes no sense to have JoyCons at all. They were created when they needed to be.



Lifetime Sales Predictions 

Switch: 159 million (was 73 million, then 96 million, then 113 million, then 125 million, then 144 million, then 151 million, then 156 million, then 161 million)

PS5: 116 million (was 105 million, then 115 million, then 122 million)

Xbox Series X/S: 38 million (was 60 million, then 67 million, then 57 million. then 48 million. then 40 million)

Switch 2: 120 million (was 116 million)

PS4: 120 mil (was 100 then 130 million, then 122 million) Xbox One: 51 mil (was 50 then 55 mil)

3DS: 75.5 mil (was 73, then 77 million)

"Let go your earthly tether, enter the void, empty and become wind." - Guru Laghima

OP I don't think that is right.
I mean yes the joycons are awesome (other than being a little small) and are perfectly designed for what the Switch is. But the entire concept of the WiiU was different and was a mess. I don't see how joycons would have done anything for the WiiU. The problem was the entire concept/design of the WiiU. Joycons only came about from Nintendo designing for the Switch concept, joycons would have made no sense with the WiiU.



No offense, but you are way off here.

Imo, the joycon suck for multiple and obvious reasons, and I won't use them.  I understand their existence because of the form factor of Switch and Sw2 and it makes sense in that instance and for some users...but to say they would have been better suited to the WiiU hardware is pretty bizarre.



Around the Network

I played Zombie-U. I played Nintendo Land. I played Splatoon. The gamepad was great. I don't blame it for lack of sales. I blame timing (that era just wasn't ready to fully embrace Nintendo again), and the fact that developers didn't take the time or invested the money into coming up with new ways to use it.



That makes zero sense



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

I think you guys are all misunderstanding the OP, all he’s getting at is that Nintendo should have went with a controller that was an evolution of the Wii Remote while also being able to serve as a standard dual stick controller rather than the Gamepad. Mentioning the size of the Joy-Cons misses the point, it’s about the concept, not the dimensions.

With that said, that alone wouldn’t have “saved” Wii U. It had a variety of issues ranging from name, marketing, price, droughts, software selection.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

Well this makes for the third Wii U thread over the past week. Lol! No idea why there's been such a resurgence in interest for this system.

Anyways, OT: I'll come to this thread after having read OP. I think it's an interesting claim worth exploring.



zorg1000 said:

I think you guys are all misunderstanding the OP, all he’s getting at is that Nintendo should have went with a controller that was an evolution of the Wii Remote while also being able to serve as a standard dual stick controller rather than the Gamepad. Mentioning the size of the Joy-Cons misses the point, it’s about the concept, not the dimensions.

With that said, that alone wouldn’t have “saved” Wii U. It had a variety of issues ranging from name, marketing, price, droughts, software selection.

Yeah. I don't mean the literal Joy-Con we have now. Rather the same basic concept of them, but for Wii U. A standard controller, split into two semi-symmetrical halves.