By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Which Series Has Best Approach to Remakes?

Tagged games:

 

Which Series Has Best Approach to Remakes?

Pokemon 0 0%
 
Resident Evil 16 76.19%
 
Final Fantasy 1 4.76%
 
The Legend of Zelda 1 4.76%
 
Metal Gear Solid 0 0%
 
Silent Hill 1 4.76%
 
Dragon Quest 1 4.76%
 
Other 1 4.76%
 
Total:21

Dragon Quest remakes are all fantastic and have all been fantastic, since the DS remakes of DQ4,5,6. it is mostly the same game with just an updated graphic engine, but keeping the art direction and musical score. In the case of DQ1 and 2 they expanded the story and updated the gameplay. 10/10 choices here.



Around the Network

Ys and Dragon Quest deserve a lot of love in this regard. Ys Oath of Felghana is one of the best remakes ever in gaming.



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

Resident Evil has by far the best track record, it's not even a competition.

Early Pokémon remakes also deserve some credit but they've sort of squandered that with time.

Final Fantasy is in a weird spot where they actually managed to make some fantastic games out of 7 that are in some ways better but also throw so much questionable stuff in the mix, taking reimagining a bit too far in terms of story.

And for Zelda... I think OoT and Majora's Mask 3D were pretty much perfect for that system but I think they've been too unambitious since then. Generally not a fan of remakes that don't tap into the full potential of remaking from scratch and Nintendo in general hates to do that.

Other huge shoutout to Black Mesa which feels like the perfect modernization that isn't too stuck up on either being "loyal" or "reinventing", making big changes where it makes sense and not doing so where it isn't necesarry.



Try out my free game on Steam

2025 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues