By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The Discussion Thread -Day #4- The 15th Annual Greatest Games Event

Runa216 said:
Veknoid_Outcast said:

#10 is correct!

#9 is something else. But you're in the right time period, as long as we go by North American release dates.

I'd say 9 is Mega Man 3 based on that hint but I'd argue 2 is more the 'blueprint' for the series. 

The game in question doesn't have a "3" or "III" in the title, even though its predecessor had a "II".



Around the Network
Veknoid_Outcast said:
Runa216 said:

I'd say 9 is Mega Man 3 based on that hint but I'd argue 2 is more the 'blueprint' for the series. 

The game in question doesn't have a "3" or "III" in the title, even though its predecessor had a "II".

A Link to the Past?



drbunnig said:
Veknoid_Outcast said:

The game in question doesn't have a "3" or "III" in the title, even though its predecessor had a "II".

A Link to the Past?

That's the one!



Let's wrap things up with the last set of clues.

#4

  • "...and with fire came disparity"

#3

  • Galactic Terran-Vasudan Alliance (GTVA)

#2

  • "Count 108 years, and when the Moon That Never Sets glows red..."

#1

  • Alexandria


#6

Change YoY: =   My Rating: 9.7 / 10

Over 15 years since its original release on the PS2, Shadow of the Colossus remains a wholly unique experience. Many have obviously tried to emulate its style, atmosphere, and tone, including the original creators, but nothing has matched what Team Ico achieved in this masterpiece. From the moment the game begins and the first notes of its introductory song 'To the Ancient Land' hit as you follow a man riding a horse through the wilderness and carrying something on his lap, it felt like I was about to experience something truly special.

There is this sense of quiet grandeur in Shadow of the Colossus that separates it from practically every other game I've ever played. Unlike so much of the medium, it isn't afraid to take its time and let the silent ambience of the world speak for itself. For vast stretches of the game, you're simply riding across the landscape with just your horse for company, just taking in your surroundings. Eventually, it becomes almost a meditative experience. However, when you do reach your destination, the atmosphere changes quite drastically as you come face to face with any one of the 16 colossi you need to take down, though the sense of melancholy that permeates the game never completely disappears, especially when some of the Colossi don't really even fight back.

Despite on the surface being about taking down 16 (mostly) huge boss monsters, in a lot of ways SotC is practically a puzzle game. Every one of the colossi needs to be taken down in a specific way, and a huge part of the fight against each is about figuring out just how to do that. It gives the game not only much of its challenge, but makes each fight unique and exciting to tackle. And then, the colossus crumbles down to the ground, the protagonist is hit by black tendrils that cause him to faint, and suddenly the feeling that something's not quite right about what you're doing rears its head once again. It's a beautiful, sad, and poignant experience, one that will undoubtedly remain with me for a very long time.



Around the Network
Runa216 said:
UnderwaterFunktown said:

Time for the final finale of finalness. Only the top 5 games of my life remain.

5) The greatest FPS, which was given away for free this year as part of it's anniversary

4) The greatest western RPG, which had a sequel revealed recently with the character you were searching for as the new lead

3) The greatest puzzle game, which doesn't need your damn lemons

2) The greatest RTS, which is still hanging in there despite the developers best attempts

1) The greatest JRPG, where the protagonist believes two swords are twice as strong as one (the math checks out)

is 4 Witcher 3? 

Correct!

the-pi-guy said:
UnderwaterFunktown said:

Time for the final finale of finalness. Only the top 5 games of my life remain.

5) The greatest FPS, which was given away for free this year as part of it's anniversary

4) The greatest western RPG, which had a sequel revealed recently with the character you were searching for as the new lead

3) The greatest puzzle game, which doesn't need your damn lemons

2) The greatest RTS, which is still hanging in there despite the developers best attempts

1) The greatest JRPG, where the protagonist believes two swords are twice as strong as one (the math checks out)

5 - Half Life 2

3 - Portal 2

2- Age of Empires II? 

5 and 3 are both right! 2 is not



Try out my free game on Steam

2024 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues:

Nintendo | PlayStation | Multiplat

Games #50 to #41
Games #40 to #31

I'm getting close to the top 20:

#30 Suikoden II

Suikoden II has one of my favorite stories in video games, thanks to all the emotionally impacting moments that it has. I felt attached to the game's characters, which are likable and well developed. The plot is engaging from beginning to end, and has some really brilliant writing, especially regarding the dichotomy between the protagonist's and Jowy's methods to achieve their objectives, and also when the characters would come up with strategies for war. I loved recluting different characters for my army, because the sidequests that you do for them to join can be pretty memorable and touching, and tell you their backstories.

#29 Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana

This is the only Ys game I've played, and I absolutely loved it. The battle system is really fast-paced, fluid, and overall highly engaging, I like that the game rewards you for knowing how to evade or block with proper timing during battles. The boss battles in this game are very well designed and require different strategies to be cleared. I also loved the island setting of the game and how, as you explore the place and discover new locations within it, you get to know more about the secrets that it hides. It is also satisfying to find castaways while exploring and to do their sidequests to know more about their personalities and get them to join your village, which they help in developing.

#28 Super Mario Galaxy 2

This game refines the Mario Galaxy formula, with levels that overall feel more complex than in the first game, and incorporate even more creative and brilliant design and puzzle ideas. I love that Yoshi returns in this game, and you can ride him in several levels designed with him in mind. The new power-ups are brilliantly implemented within the levels, I particularly enjoy the creative platforming that can be achieved by using the Cloud Mario power-up. Galaxy 2 retains the epic adventure feeling of its prequel, while also being overall more challenging. While some people disliked that they removed the Observatory hub from the first game, I like how accessing the worlds is way quicker in this game.

#27 Pokémon Platinum

My favorite Pokémon game and, honestly, I don't think it will ever be surpassed. The Sinnoh region is probably my favorite in the series, thanks to its scope, atmosphere, and the large amount of secrets that you can find in it. I love how the game contains a lot of lore regarding the origin of Pokémon and space-time, and the relationship between humans and Pokémon. The game is also brimmed with single-player content, with a whole new island to explore in the post-game, including a Battle Frontier, as well as all the optional locations that the region has for you to discover. The gym leaders and the Elite Four battles can actually be challenging, Cynthia is my favorite boss battle in the series.

#26 The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds

This game gives you the freedom to explore wherever you want from the beginning, which means that you can clear the dungeons in any order, just like in the first Zelda game. I personally did not mind the item rental system, though I can see why it can be divisive among fans. This game has my favorite overworld out of the 2D Zeldas I've played, it is very well-designed and dense, with great item usage, and has a lot of stuff for you to discover in it, from treasures to hidden caves, many of which have their own mini-puzzles and challenges. The game also makes good use of the new wall-merging mechanic for exploration. The gameplay flow is fast-paced in this and it's highly satisfying to go through the overworld.

#25 Kingdom Hearts

This game is such a magical experience, filled with tons of charm and emotional moments, the climax of this game's story is one of my favorite events in the series. Seeing Sora/Donald/Goofy interact with different Disney characters, many of whom I grew up with, was something that I really loved. I also really like the relative simplicity of the plot of this game compared with its successors and how the relationship between Sora, Donald and Goofy evolves. The worlds in this game are dense and have a certain non-linearity and intricacy to them, they are not just plain corridors like those in most of the later games before KHIII. Also, Yōko Shimomura truly killed it with the soundtrack.

#24 Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

The Thousand-Year Door is just a wonderful experience and is my favorite Mario RPG. I love its story, with all the memorable and funny events that it has, the humor in this game is excellent. The cast of main characters is so charming, and all have their own distinct personalities. I love that the different locations you visit during your adventure are so unconventional compared to the usual worlds you see in Mario games. The battle system in this game is also pretty good and is a great evolution of the Action-Command-based combat of the first game. I also really like all the different paper-based transformations Mario can use to overcome obstacles and solve puzzles in the overworld and dungeons.

#23 The World Ends With You

I love this game's Tokyo-based setting and its plot, which has lots of mysteries to solve and unexpected developments throughout it, so I always wanted to know what would happen next. The story is overall well-paced and it was very satisfying to see how everything unfolded. Another important aspect of the plot is the character development that the protagonist Neku goes through, which is very well executed, and I liked it a lot to see how his relationships with the other characters evolved over time. The battle system in this game is pretty unique, making good use of the DS touchscreen to execute different attack combos, which was very enjoyable for me. I also love the art style and the soundtrack of this game.

#22 Metroid Prime

This game is such an immersive experience, with a mysterious and lonely atmosphere that I really enjoyed. The level design in Metroid Prime is simply top-notch, I love how everything is interconnected, and the kind of progression that it has, where you can reach areas you couldn't before as you find more of Samus' gadgets, such as the Grapple Beam. Another one of my favorite aspects about this game is the subtle way it tells its story, as you get to know more about what happened in planet Talon IV while exploring and using your scanner, rather than having cutscenes with lots of exposition. The soundtrack in this is mostly very subtle and it really adds to the atmosphere.

#21 Final Fantasy IX

Final Fantasy IX has a story with a lot of heartwarming and memorable moments, and an amazing ending which is one of my favorites in RPGs. The cast of characters is just so charming and likable, with Vivi being my favorite Final Fantasy character. I also love the romance story between Zidane and Garnet, which is my favorite in JRPGs. This game features what is called Active Time Events, which allow you to see what the characters are doing when you get to a new town, and I love this because it fleshes out their personalities even more. The soundtrack is really good and I love the quirky art style. Of course, it must be said that this game is brimmed with side content, for example, I spent so many hours doing the Chocobo Hot and Cold game.



Veknoid_Outcast said:

Clues for #10-6:

#10 - The best-selling game on Switch

#9 - This game is sort of the Goldfinger of the series, because it set the blueprint for decades to come and also because it was the third installment

#8 - This game, which almost didn't make it to North America, has since spawned several sequels and remasters, one of which is due in March

#7 - There was a rumor the long-awaited sequel to this game would be announced at The Game Awards

#6 - Your best friend is on the roof in this groundbreaking game

8) Without googling what's coming in March my best guess is Suikoden

7) Half-Life 2?

Darashiva said:

Let's wrap things up with the last set of clues.

#4

  • "...and with fire came disparity"

#3

  • Galactic Terran-Vasudan Alliance (GTVA)

#2

  • "Count 108 years, and when the Moon That Never Sets glows red..."

#1

  • Alexandria

1) FF9



Try out my free game on Steam

2024 OpenCritic Prediction Leagues:

Nintendo | PlayStation | Multiplat

And then we are in the Top 10, here's everything up to #6;

10 - The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
Just when I thought there wouldn't be much that would be as good as some older games, came Breath of the Wild to the Zelda series. A big departure from what we knew and loved, but it still is a Zelda game through and through.
9 - Mario Kart 64
I try to keep nostalgia out of it, if that's possible, but this game is here in big part because of it. It's a great game by itself, but this one also means 'family' to me.
8 - SimCity 4
Might be my most played game of all time, I made entire countries in this game. I did cheat and save-game-hack my way through it though, because who likes money?
7 - Anno 1602 (1602 A.D.)
Timeless simplicity, this niche game, though today a better known series, excels at it. I actually still play it every once in a while when I'm at a friend's house, as one of the very few games.
6 - RollerCoaster Tycoon 2
Another contender for most played game, I at one point had stacks of save-files. I got very good at it if I say so myself. Especially when I found all the mods and custom objects. I did also very much cheat my way through it, because again, who likes money?
Last edited by S.Peelman - 13 hours ago

UnderwaterFunktown said:
Darashiva said:

Let's wrap things up with the last set of clues.

#4

  • "...and with fire came disparity"

#3

  • Galactic Terran-Vasudan Alliance (GTVA)

#2

  • "Count 108 years, and when the Moon That Never Sets glows red..."

#1

  • Alexandria

1) FF9

Correct.