The Uncharted trilogy is a better series so I went with that. TLOU, GTA5, GoW3 and MGS4,are better games by there lonesome or attached to much lesser games in their series. The Uncharted trilogy is emaculate fun, only stained by some platforming flaws in the first game, disappointing higher difficulty design and stealth failure states.

Uncharted 1 and 2 for sure. I can't believe people would chose tlou over it. The reason why tlou 1 was so hyped was because of the success of uncharted 2.

Though tlou series is amongst the best ever, i can't put it above uncharted. Uncharted 2 changed the games industry.

Is this poll being botted at all? I’m trying to decide on a game for Christmas break, and I’m considering whatever game comes out victorious from this poll.

These are the votes based on required login.  

and here is Anonymous voting

Basically Uncharted wins regardless. Portal 2 is far more popular with logged in users than anonymous voters though. You don't really have any bad games out of this bunch though. 

Neat! Thank you for this data. Two years ago, it was Majora’s Mask (first play-through). Last year, it was TLoU:Pt1 Remaster. This year is tbd, though Uncharted is looking to be a strong contender. Horizon Zero Dawn, God of War (any of them), and Zelda OoT are all also games I’m considering.

Uncharted series is a worthy winner; 2 was one of the most iconic games of the generation, and 1 and 3 while not quite as great were still excellent games that showed what the PS3 could do.