dane007 said:
So are you going to deny the tunnels found underneath the hospitals or the hamas leaders that got killed as he found by the refugee camp that got the after effect of the missiles that killed that hamas person?
So that doesnt could has human shields? Have you ever wondered why civilians are dying?. That's cause people in hamas group hide within the public..it's been their strategy for years. If they truly cared for its people they would sign the two state solution and live with Israel . But they won't cause they enjoy blood shed!.
You use al.jazeera who is biased towards Israel and funded by qatarians..😆 Did you not watch the link from the son of one of the co founders of hamas group.That alone trumps all the links you sent.
https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/20/middleeast/gaza-tunnel-shaft-al-shifa-hospital-intl-hnk/index.html. are you going to say that's fake? Why would you need tunnels underneath the main hospital!!
https://youtu.be/hjZbApMyANs?si=84nnGfwHiZiQ80-0
They didn't build them ..it's hamas that built then
.they shoot weapons from it. Even the son of co-founder of the group said they have tunnels everywhere underneath people's home.
I highly disappointed that you re easily swayed by hamas video and fake news. I thought you were one of the smartest member in this group.
|
|
I watched that video before, explained what's wrong with his statements. It's somewhere in this thread, no time to look for it now.
Off the top of my head, he was arrested as a teenager in Gaza, witnessed lot of traumatizing things in Israeli jails, then got enlisted and groomed by the Israel security forces.
That video trumps nothing, one brain washed individual that hasn't been part of Hamas nor been in Gaza since he was taken away by the IDF.
I've been following this a long time, haven't see any proof of fighters using civilians as shields. I've only seen proof of the IDF using (Palestinian) civilians as actual shields. (Arrest, dress them up in IDF uniform, send them out with a camera to check houses and tunnels)
Your CNN link, all that entails is
"The discovery of the tunnel shaft the next day was more compelling, showing an entrance to something underground. But even then, it was unclear what it was or how far down it went. This is what everyone has been trying to understand."
CNN reporters never went in there, the rest is some video footage released by the IDF. No independent observers (Nor is CNN since they were embedded with the IDF)
Claims of Hamas Tunnels Under Al-Shifa Hospital Debunked
https://cpcml.ca/Tmlm2023/Articles/MS53233.HTM
...
The false story that Hamas uses civilians, patients, refugees and medical personnel as human shields is repeated over and over again to suggest that Israeli atrocities and crimes are justified in order to destroy a terrorist organization driven by hate and without any conscience or humanity.
As is also the case of the false claims that Hamas murdered men, women and children, decapitated babies and raped women on October 7 and other claims which have been debunked, it turns out that "the tunnel they claim to be a Hamas tunnel is actually an electrical wire assembly point." A hospital representative said, "We raised the wires to prevent any electrical shocks caused by floods."
The other claims made by the Israeli military spokesperson on the CNN video have also been debunked. He pointed to a calendar on the wall declaring, "This is the guard list. Every terrorist has his own shift" which again CNN sensationally broadcast without question. Arabic speakers have pointed out that the calendar simply gives the days of the week since October 7, written in Arabic. The IDF spokesperson also displayed some weapons and a computer as evidence of Hamas' military operations inside the hospital. Investigators on social media analyzed the image on the laptop and found the home screen to be a picture of a female IDF soldier. A baby's milk bottle and some women's clothes were provided as evidence that hostages were held in the tunnel.
Despite facts which refute the CNN video, CNN continues to post the video on its website. Investigators say they will persist in pouring over the footage to determine whether or not these are genuine Hamas items. Given the previous cases of false evidence, along with verified accounts of the kind of carnage and revenge seeking IDF soldiers are carrying out in Gaza, such claims are cause for doubt every time.
Hamas definitely killed many men, women and a few children on Oct 7 and even if they died in the chaos of cross fire, Hamas is still responsible for their deaths. (The IDF bears some responsibility as well in the response, firing on civilians, that still needs to be further investigated)
There are many sources to debunk the tunnels at Al-Shifa and other hospitals
https://theintercept.com/2023/11/21/al-shifa-hospital-hamas-israel/
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/8/investigation-disproves-israel-claim-of-hamas-tunnel-under-gaza-hospital
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/20/what-israels-video-of-hamas-tunnel-under-al-shifa-tells-us
https://www.newsweek.com/fact-check-did-israel-build-bunker-under-shifa-hospital-1844107
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/israeli-hamas-command-center-al-shifa-hospital-falls-report-1234934784/
Plenty information out there
Qatar is a neutral mediator between Hamas and Israel. Al Jazeera is (proven) a lot more reliable than CNN/BBC etc when it comes to Gaza coverage. The bias of western media has been exposed many times as well as fabricated lies. I have not seen anything against Al Jazeera regarding Gaza and have only once found something they posted that I couldn't verify.
You're swayed by fake news without any way to back it up. These lies have been repeated for decades, indoctrination by the Israeli lobby.
Same for using ambulances to transport troops, lies to justify killing healthcare workers.
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/twilight-zone/2024-05-04/ty-article-magazine/.highlight/in-the-west-bank-not-even-ambulances-are-immune-to-israeli-army-gunfire/0000018f-3b2a-d17f-adcf-fbeb03630000
In fact the IDF dresses up as healthcare workers to raid hospitals. It's where they shot a suspect dead while in a hospital bed on life support.
Have you watched this, most from footage from the soldiers themselves
That's how the IDF operates, bunch of terrorists.
They're doing the same in Lebanon now, blowing up whole towns
Anyway what are you trying to argue? Even if Hamas has tunnels under civilian infrastructure there is still international law not making civilians that happen to be above ground legal targets. There is the law of proportionality which the IDF doesn't give a crap about. Hospitals remain off limits unless there are actual fighters in them shooting from the hospital. No evidence of that. Only of patients executed and dumped into mass graves at Al Shifa.
Documentary talking to eye witnesses after Al Shifa was destroyed
Mass graves found at Al Shifa, including women, children, people handcuffed, patients with catheters still attached.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c511k1nqx81o
The longer this goes on, the more is revealed who the actual or bigger terrorists are. And right now there's live streamed ethnic cleansing going on in the Northern part of Gaza.
Why civilians are dying is mainly because of Lavender AI and Israel's assassination tactics. How it works is that the AI targeting spits out a name of someone (loosely) affiliated with Hamas. Looks for places where they could be then assigns an air strike to target them where they are home or sleeping. The AI is far from always correct, plus when mailman pat goes home to sleep, his house with entire family and other people sheltering there gets blown up on top of them.
The IDF is using the "human shields" accusation as excuse to keep murdering civilians. Plus they shoot children in the head for sport.
April https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/02/gaza-palestinian-children-killed-idf-israel-war
September in the West Bank
https://www.dci-palestine.org/israeli_forces_fatally_shoot_two_palestinian_children_in_the_head_in_the_northern_occupied_west_bank
Anyway tunnels, human shields, burned babies, all excuses to keep the genocide and ethnic cleansing going. Excuses that hold no water as genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid, occupation are all grave crimes for which there is no excuse.
This is not a war of self-defense, it's a war of systematic extermination. To prevent a Palestinian state. It's Israel that will have to learn to live with Arabs in a 2-state solution. Qatar, Saudi-Arabia and so on are all for, and have been for, a 2-state solution. It's Netanyahu who has been trying to prevent a 2-state solution from happening since the Oslo Accords in 1996. Israel rejects the 2-state solution, not Hamas. (Although they do want it according to 1967 borders which will be very complex to figure out now. Yet you always start high in negotiations, not that there are any atm...)
Hamas revised its charter in 2017 to clarify "The new charter holds that armed resistance against an occupying power is justified under international law. While the 1988 Hamas Charter had been widely criticized for its antisemitism, the 2017 document stated that Hamas' fight was not with Jews as such because of their religion but with the Zionist project."
The more Hamas tries to go for a diplomatic solution, the more Israel tries to prevent one. Which ultimately led to Oct 7, after the border protests of 2018, 2019 and countless calls on the UN and International community to stop siege on Gaza and ongoing ethnic cleansing in the West Bank.
While Israel only went on to grab more land in the West Bank
https://www.btselem.org/publications/fulltext/202101_this_is_apartheid
2011 https://www.btselem.org/publications/summaries/dispossession-and-exploitation-israels-policy-jordan-valley-northern-dead-sea
Hamas has done horrible things in the past, Israel has done many more horrible things, long before Hamas even existed. The way forward is a 2-state solution to eventually become one country. Yet Netanyahu's Israel only wants the Palestinians gone, settle Gaza and the rest of the West Bank and now it looks like Israel wants to annex more of Lebanon.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/government-ministers-call-for-new-settlements-in-gaza-at-ultranationalist-conference/
One "Son of Hamas" video doesn't 'excuse' decades long apartheid, occupation, siege, regular atrocities ("mowing the lawn") and now full blown ethnic cleansing and genocide of the Gaza strip. Next to a war of starvation while destroying all public infrastructure making the Gaza strip unlivable.
Last edited by SvennoJ - on 21 October 2024