By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Sega hardware owners, which platform has become your new home, and why?

 

My new home is...

Nintendo 10 27.78%
 
Xbox 4 11.11%
 
Playstation 16 44.44%
 
PC 6 16.67%
 
Total:36
CatGuy said:

i could never understand the genesis > snes side of the debate.

It's called personal preference. Most debates involving console wars are just people projecting their personal preferences.  I prefer SNES but I do love Genesis. Ranxer X and MUSHA are some of the best games ever. I Just got my Retrobit copy of Gleylancer and Assault Suit Leynos is one of my fave games ever hence the name. Love that franchise in general. Again in the end I still love SNES more for it has a lot more stuff I love but it's not hard to see why some prefer it. The best part of that generation is both consoles can be argued to be equal but different. Equally different which gives us a true variety. Same with Turbografx16 the lesser talked about but still fantastic console.



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

Around the Network
Leynos said:
CatGuy said:

i could never understand the genesis > snes side of the debate.

It's called personal preference. Most debates involving console wars are just people projecting their personal preferences.  I prefer SNES but I do love Genesis. Ranxer X and MUSHA are some of the best games ever. I Just got my Retrobit copy of Gleylancer and Assault Suit Leynos is one of my fave games ever hence the name. Love that franchise in general. Again in the end I still love SNES more for it has a lot more stuff I love but it's not hard to see why some prefer it. The best part of that generation is both consoles can be argued to be equal but different. Equally different which gives us a true variety. Same with Turbografx16 the lesser talked about but still fantastic console.

the gap is still so vast, there is no way something like "personal preference" can make up for it.

for example even if you "preferred" mario andretti's street racing part 2 on genesis to super metroid on snes, would it be reasonable to have a debate on which one is better? everyone knows which one is better and its the same case here. even if people prefer genesis they know the snes is better, hence why i never understood the debate. there are things i prefer that i know are inferior to other things, i dont hide behind it being "my preference" to avoid admitting it. just sayin.



No one is comparing Mario Andretti to Super Metroid wtf are you talking about? It would be more Sonic vs Mario and Fire Emblem vs Shining Force. SNES is a better console for RPGs but Genesis is a better console for Shmups. So yes it's personal preference.



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

Leynos said:

No one is comparing Mario Andretti to Super Metroid wtf are you talking about? It would be more Sonic vs Mario and Fire Emblem vs Shining Force. SNES is a better console for RPGs but Genesis is a better console for Shmups. So yes it's personal preference.

well obviously i am making a point about how preference makes something better, which is something you brought into the discussion. im sure all the lurkers who are watching this back and forth understood that, it is hard to believe a veteran like you doesn't see what i am saying so i have to believe that you are engaging in the classic "shifting of the goal posts." 

i said that i never could understand the genesis > snes side of the debate, then you said "its called personal preference" then i said well what if someone prefers mario andretti to super metroid, does that mean that hypothetical debate would be reasonable? and now you are saying nobody is comparing mario andretti to super metroid, which isn't the point at all. do you see how that response doesnt track with the rest of the argument? you are engaging in "shifting the goalposts"

and now you are saying that snes is better for rpgs, well what if someone prefers phantasy star to anything on snes, does that make genesis better for rpg's just because of a personal preference or do you still maintain snes is better for rpgs? see, we all know what the truth is. snes is better for rpgs, genesis is better for shmups, snes is a better console, and super metroid is better than mario andretti. and mario is better than sonic too since you mention it.

Last edited by CatGuy - on 24 October 2023

Games are an inherently subjective medium; one man's trash is another man's treasure.
I prefer the SNES myself, but it's entirely possible for someone's personal tastes to align more closely with the Megadrive.
I mean, the PS2 sold like 7-8 times the Gamecube or Xbox and is widely considered the better console, but I personally enjoyed my Gamecube and my Xbox more than my PS2. It's all relative.



Around the Network
curl-6 said:

Games are an inherently subjective medium; one man's trash is another man's treasure.
I prefer the SNES myself, but it's entirely possible for someone's personal tastes to align more closely with the Megadrive.
I mean, the PS2 sold like 7-8 times the Gamecube or Xbox and is widely considered the better console, but I personally enjoyed my Gamecube and my Xbox more than my PS2. It's all relative.

Because I don't want to get into a war and peace-sized novel and sentimental things. Just keep this short. Dreamcast over PS2 for me any day and I don't dislike PS2 at all. DC is my favorite console ever but also one of my fave things to exist.



Bite my shiny metal cockpit!

DonFerrari said:

I consider myself a previous Sega fan (had the genesis for my childhood, and an Atari before that (never owned a Master System).
I did play some "pirate" NES on my friends house (we had a lot of copies in Brazil), and my childhood friend and my cousin had SNES so I played it a lot over there as well but loved Sega way more than Nintendo at the time.
I was itching to get the Saturn (my cousin had one and I played Resident Evil there and Virtua Fighter and loved it), but when I played PS1 on a school friend house I was blowback and by the time I was 15 I had the money to buy my first console by myself (I saved the school trip money I received, got like R$300 and came back with 250, plus Xmas and Bday gifts I asked all in money so I had R$500, due to currency, taxes and grey market - PS only officially released in Brazil after PS3 time - it was like enough to buy 3 consoles in USA probably - this was on January 2000 so 280USD and PS1 was 99USD by that time and very close to PS2 launch) I bought a PS1 with 2 controllers (first model), one memory card and 10 pirate SW (Final Fantasy 9, Gran Turismo and Syphon Filter were there and became my love until now).
When Dreamcast was announced I was also eager for it, but well it didn't launch for a price I could afford at the time here in Brazil and well I had to keep saving scraps of money I got from relatives so well buying a new console took another 5 years (when I got PS2, close to PS3 launch).
The main reason I got PS1 instead of N64 was basically the price of console and SW (PS1 was bootlegged only titles) and that hooked me to Sony for years, Gamecube was similar reason for me to not get and Xbox Og came to late for me to even care. By the time of X360 I considered it (my brother had it and a friend as well), and well since already had a X360 readily available to play and was anticipating GT5 and some other titles I gone PS3 (my girlfriend had a travel to Canada and I was early in my first job so I was able to send money for her to bring PS3 with guitar hero kit and Uncharted, which well I loved =p) and seeing how much MS dropped the ball on the second half of that gen I never looked back on keeping PS instead of going Xbox. Nintendo never fully served me because of the poor 3rd party support and their first party titles being more expensive (second hand market and older games still can pay a lot less on PS), but I did play a lot of Wii and loved the concept and even got Move (and well bought a Wii for my collection) and well I do have all Nintendo consoles and quite some of their best 1st party but it is more for family than for myself.

Piracy was just everywhere here, people from major markets like NA, JP and some major EU countries might not realize how much that impacted the gaming landscape here.

To this day I haven't met a person that owned the NES here back then, but loads of people with Phantom System and the likes.

People would rarely even know what having original game copies was before the PS3.

But as a fellow Brazilian it really pains me to read you writing Genesis instead of Mega Drive, seriously, lol.



curl-6 said:

Games are an inherently subjective medium; one man's trash is another man's treasure.
I prefer the SNES myself, but it's entirely possible for someone's personal tastes to align more closely with the Megadrive.
I mean, the PS2 sold like 7-8 times the Gamecube or Xbox and is widely considered the better console, but I personally enjoyed my Gamecube and my Xbox more than my PS2. It's all relative.

i like the gamecube better too but its not going to kill me to admit the ps2 was better.

some gaps are just gigantic though, like the snes vs genesis or mario andretti vs super metroid. 



CatGuy said:
curl-6 said:

Games are an inherently subjective medium; one man's trash is another man's treasure.
I prefer the SNES myself, but it's entirely possible for someone's personal tastes to align more closely with the Megadrive.
I mean, the PS2 sold like 7-8 times the Gamecube or Xbox and is widely considered the better console, but I personally enjoyed my Gamecube and my Xbox more than my PS2. It's all relative.

i like the gamecube better too but its not going to kill me to admit the ps2 was better.

some gaps are just gigantic though, like the snes vs genesis or mario andretti vs super metroid. 

"Better" is subjective though, hence it depends on the individual.



curl-6 said:
CatGuy said:

i like the gamecube better too but its not going to kill me to admit the ps2 was better.

some gaps are just gigantic though, like the snes vs genesis or mario andretti vs super metroid. 

"Better" is subjective though, hence it depends on the individual.

technically yes, but there comes a point where the gap is so wide that its irrelevant.

case in point: mario andretti vs super metroid. are you going to take someone seriously who is trying to make the case that mario andretti is the superior video game? in your heart you know this person is just plain wrong, but on the forums youll say "well thats just your opinion :)" i guess its a nice way to go about it and all, but the fact is that you know that would be an asanine argument to make.