By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Clash of the October 20th titans: Which will sell more, Mario Wonder or Spiderman 2?

 

Which will sell more?

Super Mario Bros Wonder 126 84.56%
 
Spiderman 2 23 15.44%
 
Total:149
zeldaring on 06 October 2023
RolStoppable said:
zeldaring said:

Nobody owned a wiiu so that being a port of that system doesn't really matter much, and super NSMBU is the perfect handheld game so even people that had it on wiiu most likelydouble dipped. To the average casual mario wonder just looks like another NSMBU game.

I take it, by the "average casual" you are refering to yourself.

I'm talking about mass market. just look at the commercials  they look very similar.



Around the Network
RedKingXIII on 06 October 2023
zeldaring said:
RolStoppable said:

I take it, by the "average casual" you are refering to yourself.

I'm talking about mass market. just look at the commercials  they look very similar.

They really don't. Wonder looks way more interesting in these 30 seconds then NSMBU on every commercial of the first video.



 

RolStoppable on 06 October 2023
zeldaring said:
RolStoppable said:

I take it, by the "average casual" you are refering to yourself.

I'm talking about mass market. just look at the commercials  they look very similar.

I hope you realize that your entire argument is just as bad as suggesting that Tears of the Kingdom can't possibly sell 20m copies lifetime because it's on the same console as Breath of the Wild.



Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV will outsell Super Smash Bros. Brawl. I was wrong.

zeldaring on 06 October 2023
RolStoppable said:
zeldaring said:

I'm talking about mass market. just look at the commercials  they look very similar.

I hope you realize that your entire argument is just as bad as suggesting that Tears of the Kingdom can't possibly sell 20m copies lifetime because it's on the same console as Breath of the Wild.

That's not my argument at all. I just don't think 2d mario is a big deal anymore and having one just been released not long ago that looked and played great with the same 4 player concept might not be a great thing for wonder.



zeldaring on 06 October 2023
RedKingXIII said:
zeldaring said:

I'm talking about mass market. just look at the commercials  they look very similar.

They really don't. Wonder looks way more interesting in these 30 seconds then NSMBU on every commercial of the first video.

I'll give you it's more interesting but i just don't see how anyone with a switch and likes 2d mario doesn't buy NSMU because it looks great.



Around the Network
RolStoppable on 06 October 2023
zeldaring said:
RolStoppable said:

I hope you realize that your entire argument is just as bad as suggesting that Tears of the Kingdom can't possibly sell 20m copies lifetime because it's on the same console as Breath of the Wild.

That's not my argument at all. I just don't think 2d mario is a big deal anymore and having one just been released not long ago that looked and played great with the same 4 player concept might not be a great thing for wonder.

That argument is even worse. You truly are a casual.



Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV will outsell Super Smash Bros. Brawl. I was wrong.

RedKingXIII on 06 October 2023

Saying "2D Mario is not a big deal anymore" when we have NSMBU selling 16m+ on the Switch and saying "NSMBU is a perfect handheld game and most people who bought it on Wii U double dipped on Switch" based on nothing and using YouTube views as a metric to predict that Wonder won't match the popularity of Spiderman is just... stupid.

I won't lose my time arguing anymore lmao. but I keep my prediction that Wonder will do 35m+ and Spiderman 25m+.



 

zeldaring on 06 October 2023
RedKingXIII said:

Saying "2D Mario is not a big deal anymore" when we have NSMBU selling 16m+ on the Switch, or say "NSMBU is a perfect handheld game and most people who bought it on Wii U double dipped on Switch" based on nothing or using YouTube views as a metric to predict that Wonder won't match the popularity of Spiderman is just... stupid.

I won't lose my time arguing anymore lmao. but I keep my prediction that Wonder will do 35m+ and Spiderman 25m+.

Sorry when I meant not a big deal I meant is no longer  in top 5 of Nintendo top selling ips.



KLXVER on 06 October 2023
zeldaring said:
RedKingXIII said:

Saying "2D Mario is not a big deal anymore" when we have NSMBU selling 16m+ on the Switch, or say "NSMBU is a perfect handheld game and most people who bought it on Wii U double dipped on Switch" based on nothing or using YouTube views as a metric to predict that Wonder won't match the popularity of Spiderman is just... stupid.

I won't lose my time arguing anymore lmao. but I keep my prediction that Wonder will do 35m+ and Spiderman 25m+.

Sorry when I meant not a big deal I meant is no longer  in top 5 of Nintendo top selling ips.

You base that on 1 game that was ported from the Wii U? Im not sure if that is a good indicator of how 2D Marios sell. Every new 2D Mario game is always one of the best selling games on a Nintendo console. I guess we will find out soon enough though.



zeldaring on 06 October 2023
KLXVER said:
zeldaring said:

Sorry when I meant not a big deal I meant is no longer  in top 5 of Nintendo top selling ips.

You base that on 1 game that was ported from the Wii U? Im not sure if that is a good indicator of how 2D Marios sell. Every new 2D Mario game is always one of the best selling games on a Nintendo console. I guess we will find out soon enough though.

Mario kart was ported and so was 3d world from wiiu. It selling the same as probably the least loved 3d Mario game just doesn't bold well imo of course I could be wrong it's just a prediction.