| Ryuu96 said: Just to be clear, it's a UK law, not an EU law, although the EU will very likely have a similar law in the near future, the UK is basically volunteering themselves as a test bed for this shitty law, similar laws are in some American States, the UK's law takes things a step further, it goes beyond just porn, anything which could result in a child being exposed to 18+ content is locked behind age verification now and it has been so sloppily implemented that companies don't even know what to restrict now, BlueSky is also disabling DMs unless age verified and so will others. As for Xbox, IIRC South Korea has a similar law but any account over 18 years old doesn't need to verify their identity, for Xbox I imagine if you've used a CC to purchase anything that will be another age verification method. The reason it is being expanded to other countries is because this is the direction the world is heading in unless we push back against it, stop it in the UK or else others will copy. |
I am not against age verification for child protection. But these shoddy laws put the fifth step before the first. The problem is that the age verification itself is a complicated matter, but the law just dumps the obligation to do a verification onto companies and in the case of the UK law even small organization or single persons if they have a website with communication features, but fails to specify any regulation for these verification systems. As a result I foresee a lot of tea app disasters in the future. Companies will overreach with information gathering, probably by scanning id cards, and as they will be incredibly stupid with it, things will leak. And id cards contain very sensitive informations about the people in question.
What *should* happen is that lawmakers regulate the space of age verification systems, probably through certification or better yet by offering age verification as a service from the state. This includes safety for the gathered data and assurances to only release the needed informations to clients (aka only a >18 yes/no without further informations). *Only* once certified age verification systems are running stable and early problems are ironed out, then is the time to dump the obligation to use them on website owners.













