The motion controls aren't good enough to support the game's combat premise, it is executed badly, and repetitive. 

Just because you didn't have issues doing the same 2-3 movements the whole game, doesn't mean that combat doesn't have an issue. 

So why no 'if not for Uncharted name, U4 would not have scored as well' thread from you?

Thing is though, I've actually yet to play a bad Zelda game........

There is a lot of Zelda fans out there, how would a non Zelda fan review it?

I go from my own experience and my own experience was that the were little to no issues in my own playthrough so don't try and tell me otherwise, you'll accept that whether you like it or not.

I've found that many of the people who complained about unresponsive controls were swinging the controller like mindless cavemen rather than doing slow casual swings and couldn't understand why things aren't going their way.

Because it isnt relevant, UC4 came out like a year ago

I'm not telling you, that you had issues. I'm saying that the combat is oversimplistic, repetitive, and that it fails the original premise set by Nintendo.

Yet you keep on going about how the controls responded to you. 

I imagine someone who hates Zelda would give a Zelda game a poor review.

But there's a reason there are a lot of Zelda fans out there...

your logic doesn't apply to games that are older than march 2017?...
you can insert every damn franchise and make a post like this.. it is just rediculus

Um, you think this doesn't happen with Sony or Microsoft games? Or in music? Film? There's nothing special regarding Zelda here. The games are just consistently amazing. Also, you should try to support such a claim with like, idk, actual evidence or something.