This was my reply about the topic in the amazon thread.
Switch is a hybrid, so both home and handheld console. Someone could call it portable home console. What you say, is an oversimplification.
The handheld part has detachable controllers, when you disconnect them, what do you have? Not a handheld console, but a screen/or tablet you could say, this attaches to a dock, screen turns off when its placed inside the dock, content is streamed on tv via an hdmi and we get a home console, of which the brain is the screen/tablet. The detachable controllers of the screen/tablet connect to a grip to make the controller of the home console. You are talking as if switch is like a 3DS, but you can play it on tv with a cable and a dock. .
Anyway, Nintendo calls it a home console first and foremost, so what I'm telling or you're telling doesn't matter!
Is this just a tablet that links to a keyboard? It Is a tablet that when connects to keyboard creates a laptop, with your logic it's still a tablet when its attached to the keyboard, while is obviously like a laptop.
I guess you mean that switch is primarly a handheld console and not mainly a home console, I can't believe that you really consider it a handheld console only that connects to tv with a dock. Low power for a home console todays doesn't nullify its home console capabilities.
I think you would consider it a home console if it was like wii u? Main console and tablet controller, with the difference of the tablet controller having a cartidge slot as the main console? However, that would be handheld console ( which can be used as a controller ) and home console bundled together, not a hybrid.
P.s
I was curious to see your reply to rol about wii because Ι dechipered the same thing with him from you arguments... Surely, you were not meaning that wii isn't a home console but your arguments lead to that conclusion, wii was exactly the opposite of what you described ( things get reinvented sometimes ). You could just skipped the part about philosophy and perfomance. It's kinda stereotypical.
You did right to start that discussion and I like that you don't downplay or taunt implicitly or explicitly Nintendo, you simply express your opinion with arguments, grounded or groundless, at least you have arguments, without dogmatism, unlike a specific other person, not in that thread.