I remember in one game, someone made the calculations, and then made a conclusion. If only I could remember ;_;

happened pretty much last game, though it didn't come to the calculated conclusion, it is basically draw x from y with y reducing by 2 with each unsuccessful  draw both decreasing by 1 for each successful draw, you can actually do the precise maths for it if you care to do so.

I read what you said earlier, but put on the spot - lynch or no lynch?

Get your butt in here to play, or don't you have anything to add?

If it came to it, I think I'd choose to lynch. I'm an optimist, but more importantly, I'm also curious af.

Like, how awesome would it be if we lucked out and caught scum? : D

So basically you say the information is worth it, can you just put it like that next time? If I am putting stuff in your mouth, please make me understand better.

Not angry, optimistic : D

What would happen if we lynched you? I wonder...

Either people haven't read last round or have short memories. Possibly even selective memory.
Last day 1 we had both mafia tied for lynch.
Day 1 is always good for lynching.
Especially stefl, you were the host. Very curious.

Also curious to know how you came up with your numbers. The rationalization for them, I mean.

Day 1 lynches provide tons of information, even if it does ultimately lead to a townie dying. You can analyze the votes, who was eager to vote for people, etc.

You obviously run the risk that you kill an important role (assuming this isn't vanilla, I don't recall if it has been declared as such), but without the lynch, you effectively give the mafia a free night and we start day 2 with little more than we had on day 1.

With the little we currently have, I'm going to put a vote out for Stefl. I feel like his not wanting a day 1 vote, plus really questioning those who do reeks of him wanting to get to night and avoid something catastrophic for the mafia.

Vote: Stefl

3-9 is imho best balance you can find (which only goes to 12), 4-9 and beyond seems too mafia sided, and I am assuming at least mediocre power being in the game, so neither 3-10 or 3-1-9 is out of the question to me. Then there is the OP-table displaying 5 days (which is kinda meta-gaming, but who cares).

Is anybdoy able to get a tally of who has all participated to date? I'd normally keep a spreadsheet going but am limited to my phone for the night.