Indeed. I don't think everyone would view the posts as clear evidence of Mr.P being scum, but to me they ring an alarm.

Did you know about quicktopic.com before this game?

I didn't know it existed, why? It's some sort of automatic discussion board?

I was trying to trap you into basically confirming you're mafia. Either you don't know which makes you innocent or you know enough to pretend you don't, so kudos. It's used by mafia(and some other factions, or dead players to "continue" playing along) to discuss their strategies in secret.

How do you feel about Mr.P and Xander?

I don't hink M. P is mafia, but if I were him, I wouldn't disclose his role so quickly. I mean, we haven't even taken out someone yet, it's too soon to reveal who is who. I'm with Axumblade in that, this soon in the game, nobody is an almost confirmed town or mafia, and we're basically pointing fingers blindly. As for Xander, I can't get a lecture on him yet, too few information-fuelled posts to know.

Votals

Ssince the lynch rules are not clear, I'll elaborate to remove any uncertainty, hopefully

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 lynch. In case of not reaching enough for a lynch, the player that has the most votes will be lynched. A tie will result in no lynch

History

stefl votes spurge
finalfan votes darwin
finalfan unvotes
axum votes spurge
prof votes stefl
baalzamon votes stefl
miz votes stefl
finalfan votes spurge
finalfan unvotes
axum unvotes
stefl votes prof
linkz votes mr. p
baalzamon unvotes
miz votes noctis
finalfan votes mr. p
mr. p votes xander
stefl votes mr. p
baalzamon votes mr. p
finalfan unvotes
finalfan votes xander

Guys, I get all the suspicion on Mr.P, I really do. But the Xander situation is intolerable, and he's clearly determined to be just active enough to avoid a modkill and no more.

I'll give it a shot.  I reviewed the posts before and after your initial offer, and there were several things that stood out, but many of them you'd already confronted him on.  There were also some oddities that I didn't see him saying both before and after, such as admitting lurking and seeming to whine about how unfair it is that Xander gets away with lurking more easily than he does. 

My pick for what you were talking about is his fixation on the makeup of the scum team.  There was widespread silly talk about the size of the mafia team early in the game, but Mr.P takes it a step farther and seems very certain about just who is on the team.  It has to have a pro, because the mod would be sure to put a pro on the mafia team "or it would be suicide".  (Although this juxtaposes oddly with his later claim that "mafia is already OP", which justified putting a lurker on the mafia team.  But he wondered in disbelief at the idea of the mod giving that same lurker an important role?)  He said Xander is likely "the noob scum", and in one post seemed to indicate that he wants to go after pros that seem scummy on the theory that it's the best way to flush out the seasoned leader of the mafia team that must exist according to him, personally hand-picked by the moderator. 

One "pro" and two noobs as understudies seems to be the prevailing train of thought here, based on nothing but pure imagination—or personal knowledge. 

On another topic:  Linkz, I was paying attention to the relationship between Darwin and Stefl, because I remember something was said about that, like Darwin was possibly buddying up to Stefl because they were mafia together or something.  Well, I watched what they were saying while I was looking for Mr.P's posts and your challenge, and it seemed to me like it was closer to the other way around—that Stefl was acting very warmly towards Darwin.  You said you analyzed Stefl back then, but I don't see anything you said back then on the specific topic of Stefl and Darwin.  Could you give your thoughts on this?  Supposing that exactly one of Stefl and Darwin were mafia, my feeling right now would be at least 70% odds on Stefl.  But then again I voted for Hillary. 

I can get behind a Xander lynch tbh... I am kinda day-tired by now (specially since i know I am a bit more busy until next tuesday) - but I really think we should give Xander like around 36 hours total before lynching him, because I know how much work it can be to catch up on literally everything that happened, even though it would be a lynch scum can get behind quite ez if he is town and I would not really consider it valueable.

VGChartz has been broken for me guys. I'll have to withdraw.