By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Do you consider cheesecake a cake or a pie?

 

Cheesecake is what?

Cake 58 52.25%
 
Pie 36 32.43%
 
Other 17 15.32%
 
Total:111

Cake. It's even in the name of it. xD



Around the Network
Zappykins said:
SuaveSocialist said:
I think it would be a cake; every pie I can think of is composed of either fruit, vegetable or meat.

Where does Mincemeat Pie fall?  (It's not made of meat despite it's name.)

Mincemeat is spiced, dried fruit--although originally it always had meat.  So it would be pie either way.



d21lewis said:
Is it even cheese!?!

Yes.  The primary ingredient is cream cheese.  



I would have to say pie, because cake generally has frosting and is lighter and fluffier. Cheesecake also has a crust, which cake does not. I mean, no one would call pumpkin pie a cake, and they're extremely similar.



Cake, it's a cake.

A pie crust is universally either pastry or bready. The cheesecake base is never either of these. It is a crumbed biscuit (cookie for Americans) base. Since a biscuit (cookie) is basically a hard, flat cake a cheesecake is basically like a thin, hard crumbled cake with an extremely thick and dense layer of a cream cheese icing.

It has the appearance of a pie, especially when baked, but the content is pure cake.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

Around the Network
binary solo said:
Cake, it's a cake.

A pie crust is universally either pastry or bready. The cheesecake base is never either of these. It is a crumbed biscuit (cookie for Americans) base. Since a biscuit (cookie) is basically a hard, flat cake a cheesecake is basically like a thin, hard crumbled cake with an extremely thick and dense layer of a cream cheese icing.

It has the appearance of a pie, especially when baked, but the content is pure cake.

This did not make sense at all.

 

The pastry itself IS a cake. Just because pies have pastry that does not make them anything like cake as you are implying to happen with cheesecakes. Cake+large filling = pie. Cheesecakes are pie, and have cake on the bottom and sides like every other pie.



Gourmet said:
binary solo said:
Cake, it's a cake.

A pie crust is universally either pastry or bready. The cheesecake base is never either of these. It is a crumbed biscuit (cookie for Americans) base. Since a biscuit (cookie) is basically a hard, flat cake a cheesecake is basically like a thin, hard crumbled cake with an extremely thick and dense layer of a cream cheese icing.

It has the appearance of a pie, especially when baked, but the content is pure cake.

This did not make sense at all.

 

The pastry itself IS a cake. Just because pies have pastry that does not make them anything like cake as you are implying to happen with cheesecakes. Cake+large filling = pie. Cheesecakes are pie, and have cake on the bottom and sides like every other pie.

No, pastry is not a cake. 



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

No idea but I knpw it's not very tasty.



binary solo said:
Gourmet said:

This did not make sense at all.

 

The pastry itself IS a cake. Just because pies have pastry that does not make them anything like cake as you are implying to happen with cheesecakes. Cake+large filling = pie. Cheesecakes are pie, and have cake on the bottom and sides like every other pie.

No, pastry is not a cake. 

And biscuit is? Ok, keep telling yourself that, good luck.



Cheesecakes in the USA typically have a crumbled graham cracker crust. For those of you not familiar with American graham crackers, they generally are flavored with honey and/or cinnamon, and are pretty sweet. They look like crackers, but, IMHO they're closer to cookies than crackers, in the American sense.