Ka-pi96 said:
burninmylight said:
That theory is garbage and has been debunked since Gen 2. Cyndaquil is not a freaking rat.
|
I dunno. Cyndaquil is the 'fire mouse Pokemon'. And a rat is really just a big mouse. Considering Cynda is far bigger than your average mouse it's not really strange to think of it as a rat.
|
Lol, this is the same Pokedex that calls Blastoise a shellfish, calls Hypno a child abductor and says that a little boy had a Kafka-like metamorphosis and turned into Kadabra. Those English Pokedex entries aren't canon at all, and the translators really pulled ideas out of their ass in earlier games where there was less emphasis placed on consistency across regions.
A rat is no more of a big mouse moreso than a chihuahua is a big rat with less hair. A wolf is not a big dog. It is a wolf. A scorpion is not a spider. There is a reason we have different kingdoms, classes, families and species of animals and so on.
If Sugimori wanted Cyndaquil to be a rat, he wouldn't have drawn an something with traits of echidnas/shrews/honey badgers/porcupines and made 山荒 yama-arashi part of it's Japanese name, with yama-arashi meaning porcupine. Nowhere in that cocktail does Cyndaquil resemble a rat. Same with it's evolved forms.
Are you one of the people that still hold on to the idea that all the grass starters are based on prehistoric animals, even though Treecko, Snivy and Chespin (and now Rowlet) exist?