By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Petition: Remove Uncharted 4 Washington Post Review from Metacritic

Cobretti2 on 16 May 2016

LOL meanwhile some naked girls had to please themselves when the men rallied to fix this life changing issue.



 

 

Around the Network
KLXVER on 16 May 2016
Cobretti2 said:
LOL meanwhile some naked girls had to please themselves when the men rallied to fix this life changing issue.



TheSting on 16 May 2016
Cobretti2 said:
LOL meanwhile some naked girls had to please themselves when the men rallied to fix this life changing issue.

3rd world problems here man. Of all the things to protest. Really? If Metacritic changes the score because of this nonsense then they should just shut down altogether. Can't believe ppl are taking this serious and it's a few who are borderline psycho about it. 



Luke888 on 16 May 2016

While I agree that an Ironic review should be removed from Metacritic if confirmed to be ironic from the person who wrote it (I don't know if this is the case) I also agree with the fact that this is pure fanboy-ism and someone might argue that as the game doesn't deserve a score as low as 4/10 it doesn't even deserve a 10/10.
Of course the same happened previously with other fanboys, for example the 7.8 Too much water given by IGN to Pokémon ORAS so don't take my comment as an attack to Sony/Uncharted fans...



LMU Uncle Alfred on 16 May 2016

Then we should get Famitsu back.



Lube Me Up

Around the Network
KLXVER on 16 May 2016
LMU Uncle Alfred said:
Then we should get Famitsu back.

Famitsu is gone?



LMU Uncle Alfred on 16 May 2016

Yeah, as far as I can see.  I haven't seen a famitsu review in a while on meta.  Can someone show me otherwise of a recent Famitus review on meta?  They contain no less integrity than a lot of other reviewers these days.  More text written on a review is not more legit.



Lube Me Up

LMU Uncle Alfred on 16 May 2016
KLXVER said:
LMU Uncle Alfred said:
Then we should get Famitsu back.

Famitsu is gone?

Sorry for double post (Why doesn't the reply button work on the last quote?  Or any quotes?)

Yeah, as far as I can see.  I haven't seen a famitsu review in a while on meta.  Can someone show me otherwise of a recent Famitus review on meta?  They contain no less integrity than a lot of other reviewers these days.  More text written on a review is not more legit.



Lube Me Up

thismeintiel on 16 May 2016
Nem said:

Oh someone has a different opinion than you? That can not be allowed!

You know what that is called? Fascism! Yeah... i find this petition absolutely disgusting and anti-freedom of speech.

You realize that the people who created the petition are expressing theirs as well? It's up to WP and MC to respond to it, which are private companies and can do as they wish.  If it was an oversized government stepping in to either silence the reviewer or force it to stay up, because they agreed with it, that would be fascism. The more you know.

@ OP

This happens with every highly anticipated release.  You'll have a few knuckleheads rate it below average just for the recognition and traffic.  If they review like everyone else, it gets lost in a sea of praise.  If you weakly defend a very low score, you'll get tons of angry fans clicking on your review.  Pathetic, but a part of life.



 

CenterYharnham on 16 May 2016
Nate4Drake said:
nanarchy said:
What a sad individual to make such a pointless petition. Metacritic has always sucked, there will always be bad reviews or reviews that you disagree if. If you don't like it then DON'T READ METACRITIC. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, even if we think it is childish and idiotic, we don't live in a dictatorship (at least I don't) where we need to be told what to think or write.

Negative!

That was not an opinion, that was not a Review;  it was a Joke or utter gargabe, one of the two; so it must me removed.  Quality control ;) 

You haven't even played the game yet...