Its a bit hard to tell with Digital sales becoming more popular. I still think Halo will sell more life time. One of the best MP games going around with constant updates. Halo 5 might not have sold as much on launch but Halo games have some of the best legs in the business. Uncharted will most likely sell 6m however I see Halo 5 selling 6+m at the end of the life circle. (Digital included)

The better question is would Uncharted sell more if the Userbase was the same size.

Yep, Halo could sell a ton of mechandise and Uncharted can't. Halo has TV series, Uncharted doesn't. Uncharted isn't going to to be a bigger franchise anytime soon if ever. Remember this is Naughty Dogs last Uncharted.

Crazy how gamers will just assume things based off hype and no research. Halo is a monster and one of the biggest franchises going around in gaming. Uncharted has died with its last game. Sure its a great game, sure it will sell millions like most AAA games do, but a bigger franchise then Halo is actually quite laughable. 

Agreed. If anything, Halo is the series that seems to be dying.

Are the OT talking about retail only?

Should we include bundles?

You can admit it, man. Hell, there is no denying it at this point. Halo IS NOT that popular anymore. How much did Halo 4 sell compared to 3? How much has Halo 5 sold so far? Uncharted 4 has already sold almost as much as Halo 5 and it's only been out 3 weeks.

Uncharted 4 will win by a landslide and that's a fact at this point

Well I'm bias, but UC is simply on another lvl and has been since UC2. Now the franchise is set to end so it should be expected.

2,7 includes digital and bundles.

We have no idea how acurated vgchartz numbers are, but it's only retail só far.

Halo 5 could be up to 7mi total.

Halo 5 will sell at least 5 million retail, likely over 6 million. Sorry, but I doubt Uncharted 4 will do 10-12 million even with digital (unless it becomes the main PS4 bundle).