By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End Review Thread - MC: 93 / GR: 92.70%

Tagged games:

CrazyGPU on 05 May 2016

prebought it - Waiting for the download.



Around the Network
Pavolink on 05 May 2016
RolStoppable said:

I predict a Metascore of 94, so a moderate critical flop.

Spoiler:

You are foolish for reading this. You could have seriously spoiled the game for yourself. For Nathan's sake, restrain yourself! 

So, critical flop. You should start your career as a fortune teller.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


CWegzz on 05 May 2016

So unless I'm mistaken, Uncharted 4 is now the highest rated non port/remastered 8th gen game. So congrats to Naughty Dog on this.



Wii U NNID:  CWegzz
3DS Friend Code:  4210-5277-5484
PSN:  Ronnoc4
Steam:  CWegz

Ruler on 05 May 2016
Dadrik said:
Ruler said:

Yeah last gen. This gen all liniar games flopped so for in metacritic, but these reviewers at metacritic seem to make an exeption for Naughty Dog.

U4 doesnt have different endings either

Do you really struggle to accept the fact that all linear games so far this gen have been underwhelming while Naughty Dog nailed it, as they've been doing it since the first Crash Bandicoot ?

That's kinda sad. 

Well why has rise of the tomb raider gotten a 86 then? it wasnt liniar, and no liniar game with zero back tracking deserves such a high score like 94 to be honest. Its unfair to all the other games who give a huge effort designing their maps etc.



Why i left PC gaming

 

(2015) Question for PS4 owners: if the situation would be reverse? would you still play on PS4?

(2015) The "I don't care PS4 is the most powerful console" thread

Swordmasterman on 05 May 2016
CGI-Quality said:
Azzanation said:

I am not wishing upon a bad review but it only takes 1 troll review to ruin its 90s meta. Forza Horizon 2 reviewed a 2/10 out of its 85 reviews. Uncharted 4 will most likely gain another 30 reviews for its AAA appearence. You never know. As for the score 8.8 is what i guessed from IGN for its campaign (Dont care for the MP)

8.8 is still fantastic. Metacritic has become a joke lately. MGS5 sits on a 93 and that game was not by any means a GOTY game.  UC4 might still sit in the 90s and i would say its lowest could be a 8.8 but i think a 9.2 is reasonable.

It would take much, MUCH more than one "troll review" to drop the score 6 points. So no, that won't happen.

I Don't think that  Any source of Video Game Journalism make "Troll Reviews".



Around the Network
TheBlackNaruto on 05 May 2016
Ruler said:
Dadrik said:

Do you really struggle to accept the fact that all linear games so far this gen have been underwhelming while Naughty Dog nailed it, as they've been doing it since the first Crash Bandicoot ?

That's kinda sad. 

Well why has rise of the tomb raider gotten a 86 then? it wasnt liniar, and no liniar game with zero back tracking deserves such a high score like 94 to be honest. Its unfair to all the other games who give a huge effort designing their maps etc.

WHy does it not deserve it and how is it now fair to other games? Maybe ROTR got an 86 because it was a good game just not as good as UC4...is there something wrong with that? Neither is a bad game so what is the issue? Maybe UC4 executed things better than ROTR and was for fulfilling...I don't get what the issue you have with the score is.....also side note..... Are you the same person who made the FFXV grpahics thread?



The absence of evidence is NOT the evidence of absence...

PSN: StlUzumaki23

poklane on 05 May 2016

Giant Bomb: 5 stars http://www.giantbomb.com/reviews/uncharted-4-a-thiefs-end-review/1900-744/
Looking very likely that it will stay at 94 metacritic now, unless IGN's final review is a 10/10 or way below their current score of 8.8. And even then it might stay at 94.



Kerotan on 05 May 2016
CrazyGPU said:
prebought it - Waiting for the download.

My pre order was cancelled for some reason.  Had to go and repreorder it yesterday lol.  Just aswell I found out so it will be downloaded and ready. 



Bryank75 on 05 May 2016

Oh my luuurd, Giant Bomb delivering the goods! Nice :)

Take that Lucy O'Brien, disgrace to gaming journalism.



-Ack!- on 05 May 2016
TheBlackNaruto said:
Ruler said:

Well why has rise of the tomb raider gotten a 86 then? it wasnt liniar, and no liniar game with zero back tracking deserves such a high score like 94 to be honest. Its unfair to all the other games who give a huge effort designing their maps etc.

WHy does it not deserve it and how is it now fair to other games? Maybe ROTR got an 86 because it was a good game just not as good as UC4...is there something wrong with that? Neither is a bad game so what is the issue? Maybe UC4 executed things better than ROTR and was for fulfilling...I don't get what the issue you have with the score is.....also side note..... Are you the same person who made the FFXV grpahics thread?

@Ruler

Seriously? What's wrong with linear games, and why on default non-linear games would be better? Also larger areas don't necessarily take more effort they just take different kind of effort. And also the scores are not based on effort, but the end result of that effort.

Sure we have opinions but saying that [non-linear > linear]  is always the case is BS. By those standards we should base review scores on map size.

IMO non-linearity ruined Metal Gear series, (but It's great in Warrior Within) yet I understand why many people liked MGSV. Whether linearity is a good thing is based entirely on the game at hand, the same shoes just won't fit every feet...