d21lewis said: -Villain who is almost nothing like their comic book counterpart? -Killing people in an African community? -A black person condemning the actions of a hero who is above the law? -A hero hearing the name of someone they care about and suddenly losing their nerve? -Heroes using lethal force against people who were just doing their jobs? -The reveal of hero/heroes identity by "found footage" -a battle between good guys that could have been avoided by conversation -a meeting to establish a hero's limits ends in an explosion -the death of a parent/parents deciding a pivitol action at the end of the movie -some guy loses their ability to walk -virtually no change to the status quo despite some major things happening that SHOULD have long term ramifications -a villain ending up in prison but still feeling like they've won But one film will be condemned while another is praised. |
Because one was done well, with good writing, likeable characters you could enjoy watching, and had some heart and soul behind it.
The other was dour, stupid, poorly made, and done with more style than substance.
Batman b Superman had some great themes and ideas in it, all poorly handled throughout without any true depth of character, poor writing, and....I just need to stop. The box office receipts combined with reviews and ticket sale patterns show people HATED Batman v Superman but quite loved Civil War. Neither were flawless, but it's clear from virtually every metric which one was the better film and why.
My Console Library:
PS5, Switch, XSX
PS4, PS3, PS2, PS1, WiiU, Wii, GCN, N64 SNES, XBO, 360
3DS, DS, GBA, Vita, PSP, Android