He specifically mentioned that Evil Within was too scary for him.  Otherwise it would've been second.

I would skip The Order. It's gorgeous but it doesn't play very well.

Gravity Rush is an excellent game that kind of falls apart in the final act.

I haven't played Alien Isolation, unfortunately.

If the new Ratchet is anything like the old games, I'm sure it's great.

Good luck!

Imo it's more atmospheric than scary but you're probably right :)

Edit:

Alien

If money weren't an issue, go with R&C. Otherwise, go with Gravity Rush.

Went with R&C. It's already downloading on my PS4 should be ready by the time I get home from work.

LoL, R&C eclipses those other choices. If it was me it would be between R&C or Dark Souls 3.

Ratchet of course.

No love for GR

Dark Souls is to much for me. I've never beaten a Dark Souls game in my life and even BloodBorne I haven't beaten. I enjoy those games but I always get bored of them when I'm about halfway through. Dark Souls 1 I stopped at Blightttown right before the boss, BloodBorne I stopped at the spider boss. I always buy those games in the $20 range cause then I still get my monies worth that way.