Uncharted looks insane and it is going to be awesome!!!
But imo there is no game which looks better than reality yet. There is still a long time until developers will make these kind of games (if it is even possible).

lol, no.

1. As soon as people start moving around you can tell it's just a game.
2. I can understand games with a more fantasy art style being more appealing than "real life" to some people, but that isn't what ND is trying to do, they're going for realism, and no, not even close to real life.

You need to go outside more, OP. lol

It does look better than most iphone pictures of real life, though.

Depends where you live

Even though its beautiful, I feel like the true beauty of nature trumps game visuals any day and it will always be the case

Blah I need to hurry up and beat UC3. Think I'm on chapter 14-15.

We are not there yet (and we probably never will) but it does look pretty damn good.

UC4 looks really, really good - better then real life, though? No, not really.

I'd say it will take a gen, probably even two, and some bold art directions (neo-surrealism, to be precise) for that feel, at least for me.

Deep Down has a chance

Better than life, no that would be Red Dwarf