So we have sales of both microsoft and Sony, and I'm sure there will be some surprises and shocks on here. Note these are retail sales, so they don't include digital. And these are without bundle's.

XBO LTD:

Halo 5: Guardians - ~1.7m (rounded from 1.699m)
Forza Motorsport 6 - ~451k
Gears of War: Ultimate Edition - ~371k
Rise of the Tomb Raider - ~345k
Rare Replay - ~239k
State of Decay: Year One Survival Edition - ~81k

PS4 LTD:

Bloodborne - ~754k
MLB 15: The Show - ~626k
The Order: 1886 - ~357
Uncharted : The Nathan Drake Collection - ~259k
Until Dawn - ~330k
God of War III Remastered - ~162k
Tearaway Unfolded - ~24k

You can decide what you think of this. Though what beat me expectations, well Rare Replay did FAR better than I was expecting. It was a really niche title, and coming from a "dead" developer, I'm happy to see it did so well. MLB also did very well compared to what I expected, and Until Dawn was also another sales surprise. The Order 1886, Halo 5, and Uncharted did disappoint compared to what I expected in terms of sales. while the rest seem fine. 

Poor Tearaway Unfolded :(

I wish they had promoted that game better, it's a real gem!

Nothing out of the ordinary really. Beside already knowing that ROTTR flopped and Halo "underperforming", they are pretty much what I expected.

Most of gears and uncharted sales are bundles which should put them above 1m.

I think Tearaway would have sold poorly either way. It's not a shooter, action adventure with swords or anything else which is popular. People possibly also pass it off as a kids game. It's a damn shame as it's an awesome game.

From December NPD

Gears of War: Ultimate Edition > 800k (including bundles)

I'm sure I see the NDC figures with bundles somewhere.

MS disappointing numbers considering Halo 5.

Sony doing well considering the delay of Uncharted 4 and the bundles of NDC not being counted and their third party approach last year.

Bloodborne is a beast in sales

These are NPD numbers?

Yeah, they're in the NPD thread as well.