I'd be very surprised if Uncharted 4 didn't sell more (thanks to TLOU and the PS4's success, it seems to have maintained more of its relevancy), but i think it's up in the air as to which will score better. I'm expecting both to settle in the 90 - 93 range.

I have to say Uncharted 4 for both. Game is shaping up to be something special like UC2 and TLOU. There doesnt seem to be much hype around Gears 4. Looking at youtube views, Gears 4 gameplay reveal is barely above 1 million, while Uncharted 4 has multiple multi million trailers, the highest at over 9 million (the gameplay reveal).

METASCORES:

- Uncharted: 88

- Gears of War: 94 (winner)

----------------------------

- Uncharted 2: 96 (winner)

- Gears of War 2: 93 

----------------------------

- Uncharted 3: 92 (winner)

- Gears of War 3: 91

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

SALES:

- Uncharted 1: 4.91 

- Gears of War: 6.09 (winner)

------------------------------

- Uncharted 2: 6.67

- Gears of War 2: 6.74 (winner)

-------------------------------

- Uncharted 3: 6.78 (winner)

- Gears of War 3: 6.20

Well, id say that Uncharted 4 will win both categories.

The Meta Score is a sure thing, there is no debate here.

The sales from the X360 franchises havent reflected on the X1 counterparts, ex: Halo and Forza. So i will say that Uncharted 4 will also sell better than Gears of War 4.

Uncharted will most likely win both.

That said, I think Gears of War 4 will be the biggest and the best Gears game yet. I have a feeling they'll be bringing something great to the table with campaign and most importantly, with the multiplayer. Rod Ferguson is on board and they can learn from Epics fuckups with the franchise. Gameplay revealed showed that they're back to that dark, grim Gears of War, can't wait!

I haven't played much Uncharted but I didn't find these games similar at all so why the metacritic comparison? :P

Splatoon dus

But seriously Gears of War has the God of War syndrome after a great triology. It had a decent prequel and people don't know what to expect. While Uncharted 4 is another great sequel to end a loved franchise. I don't see the latter lose either.

Well they where the most succesful exclusive triologies of the last gen (if you don't count the prequel). They where both highly rated and sold well so I guess that's why. 

looking at vgchartz, and it looks like Uncharted killed Gears whit fire in first week worldwide and, alson, in USA.

There really isn't much crow to be served in this thread huh? Very few people doubted what was pretty obvious even back in January.

Uncharted 4 is a beast!

Wow. Uncharted 4 just killed everything