Forums - Gaming Discussion - One gotta go: Survival Horror Edition

Which one gotta go?

Silent Hill 10 24.39%
Fatal Frame 20 48.78%
Resident Evil 11 26.83%

We are back with the second edition of "One gotta go". I´m still off school for a couple of weeks so I may be able to do this daily.

The results of the first edition are here, and with a shocking (at least for me) 54% of the votes Crash Team Racing  is the kart racer that has to go.


It´s time for a new contest, please read before you vote because some people misunderstood and voted wrong.

So what´s this thing about? easy, I choose 3 games (or franchises) of the same genre (or similar) and you pick the one you would eliminate from history (meaning it never existed so you never got a chance to play it)


Let´s take a look at the 3 franchises of this edition:








So, Which one gotta go?






Around the Network

Really, really hard question.

Basing on my history with the franchise (i.e. almost nonexistant), the one that I think has to go is Fatal Frame.

Hard question but for me...Fatal Frame is the one that has to go...

The absence of evidence is NOT the evidence of absence...

PSN: StlUzumaki23

Fatal Frame. The other 2 have had a very significant impact on the genre.

bet: lost

Fatal Frame. It's not as big as the other two franchises.

Around the Network

It really hurts to say but Resident Evil needs to go, because it's not survival horror anymore.

Gameplay > Graphics

Substance > Style

Art Direction > Realism

I gotta go with RE as it never was good at horror

Roronaa_chan said:
I gotta go with RE as it never was good at horror


Let's get rid of Silent Hill.

Resident Evil has the best gameplay.
Fatal Frame has chicks.
Silent Hill has locked doors.

It's an easy choice.

Legend11 correctly predicted that GTA IV (360+PS3) would outsell SSBB. I was wrong.

A Biased Review Reloaded / Open Your Eyes / Switch Gamers Club

I liked RE CV so not that one. Silent hills movies were good imo. Never touched fatal frame so that one :P