By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA V was the last "Top 20 games of all time" worthy game, which game will be next?

champybh on 03 December 2015

further more ... if you combine critic and avg user scores the top 20 of all time gets resorted to the following on metacritic

1 Ocarina of Time
2 Resident Evil IV
3 Super Mario Galaxy 2
4 Golden Eye 007
5 Tekken 3
6 Twilight Princess
7 Soul Calibur
8 Orange Box
9 Half-life
10 Super Mario Galaxy
11 Perfect Dark
12 Bio Shock
13 Mass Effect 2
14 Wind Waker
15 Uncharted 2
16 Halo
17 GTA III
18 Arkham City
19 Skyrim
20 GTA V



run away! 

Around the Network
Chasesdaddy84 on 03 December 2015
champybh said:
further more ... if you combine critic and avg user scores the top 20 of all time gets resorted to the following on metacritic

1 Ocarina of Time
2 Resident Evil IV
3 Super Mario Galaxy 2
4 Golden Eye 007
5 Tekken 3
6 Twilight Princess
7 Soul Calibur
8 Orange Box
9 Half-life
10 Super Mario Galaxy
11 Perfect Dark
12 Bio Shock
13 Mass Effect 2
14 Wind Waker
15 Uncharted 2
16 Halo
17 GTA III
18 Arkham City
19 Skyrim
20 GTA V

Why did you write Resident Evil 4 like that? No where is it listed like that... it's really bothering me ;p ... but seriously lol 



method114 on 03 December 2015

 

Roronaa_chan said:
GTA V ain't even in the top 500


Didn't even like GTA V at all. I tried to play it but the story is really really boring. Why am I towing cars in two different missions? I understand one mission but two? GTFO. The story was a mess and was done much better in GTA 4 which I really really enjoyed.



TheLastStarFighter on 03 December 2015

Zelda U, if not, EAD Tokyo's Mario NX. I think it's going to be something special.



Azuren on 03 December 2015

GTAV was only popular with GTA fans, which there are admittedly a lot of.

However, I don't believe that it is Top 20 material. It's a good, ambitious game... But there are much better games with wider appeal.



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

Around the Network
Azuren on 03 December 2015
champybh said:
further more ... if you combine critic and avg user scores the top 20 of all time gets resorted to the following on metacritic

1 Ocarina of Time
2 Resident Evil IV
3 Super Mario Galaxy 2
4 Golden Eye 007
5 Tekken 3
6 Twilight Princess
7 Soul Calibur
8 Orange Box
9 Half-life
10 Super Mario Galaxy
11 Perfect Dark
12 Bio Shock
13 Mass Effect 2
14 Wind Waker
15 Uncharted 2
16 Halo
17 GTA III
18 Arkham City
19 Skyrim
20 GTA V

Hmm... No Shadow of the Colossus... No Super Mario World... Yet Twilight Princess is there... 

 

Wind Waker instead of Majora... Soul Caliber instead of Soul Caliber 2... Halo, but no Halo 2... Oh, there's a Mass Effect in there, cute... Galaxy AND Galaxy 2, that can't be right...

 

Sorry, but this first draft is just... It's just awful. 



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

atomicblue on 03 December 2015

GTA V? Ugh. No.



pkmnMasterWheeeIer on 03 December 2015

Zelda U and Uncharted 4 are strong candidates I think



DakonBlackblade on 03 December 2015

Who made these criteria, they make no sense specialy considering reviewers have been much more strict with the score son this generation. you cant realy compare metascore over the course of like 20 years and use it as a base for a list.

Also we all know Zelda has already reviewed at like 98, its Zelda it has 10 extra points for being Nintendo and another 10 for being Zelda, so if its an 80 ppl will give it 100. Actualy it has another 10 extra points for being Open World, wich is another thing that gives games free extra points on reviewers mind. It has 10 for Nintendo + 10 for Zelda + 10 for Open Worldness.