Physical

Physical with the exception of huge digital sales....

I prefer physical because you get the actual game, so you can sell it, stack it, take pictures of it..

But since I mainly get Nintendo games, the physical prices are the same as the digital versions so why not get the disc/cartridge?

I have a shelf and I'd be dammed if I didn't use it!

This comparison is very flawed.

i prefer physical copies of the game except if it is insanely cheap on digital.
i don't think a lot of countries have a great internet speed and consoles would still have optical discs in it to cater for that audience.

I've gone all-digital this gen. I don't regret it as it's brilliantly convenient, but I do kind of miss having the game boxes and the smell of a new game.

If digital is cheaper then why do all big name release launch at $60 both digital and physical? It's a big profit margin off digital games to not have to pay retail stores, shipping, packaging, ect... yet their still charging us full retail... Also not everyone has the internet speeds to download a 50+ gig game and even with a high internet speed it's still gonna take half the day if not longer before you can play it. Sure there's predownloading but not every company offers that.

Physical Copies Perks

*Fully owning the game to sell it, rent it, loan it. What if you buy a rare game that becomes rare yet you bought it digitally? Your stuck with it then.

*Buying used can equal giant savings if you buy the games months after release which is a nice option.

*Always having the game and not worrying about if one day the severs the games are hosted on will go down and be lost forever because let's be honest, somewhere down the line digital games will be lost maybe 2 or 3 console generations down the road.

*Collector's Editions are rarely digitally outside big name games.

*HDD space isn't an issue if you are not required to install the game.

*A lot of niche games are not digital.

*ISP download limits do not affect physical games.

Just to hit a few key points you didn't include and sure Digital has its perks as well but its not for all of us.

No benefit at all for buying air and a license to play a game for that amount of money with knowing when the servers go down or the company goes down its game over for your games.

Physical ftw Always.

Digital only era will come and i wont be part of it.

When I physically own a game, I'm dependent on myself as to how, what,where, when, etc. I can do with it. With digital, I'm more of a slave to a service.