By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Who Won E3 2015 - IGN Versus Results

_Jameson on 07 July 2015
DerNebel said:
_Jameson said:
Aerys said:


And COD will outsel Halo so COD > Halo ?-


I'm not debating quality, there's obviouly a ton of great games for ps4 players to play. but that list is overvaluing a ton of titles that won't be relevant this hoildays. 

Believe me, if we're talking about what is going to be relevant this holiday season then you can pretty much scratch anything but Halo from the Xbox list as well, maybe Forza because it hits a certain audience.

Tomb Raider will sell 1-2m minimal with potential for more, which will still out sell a hand full of does games on that list.



Around the Network
Dulfite on 07 July 2015

Minus the 2016-2018 games, and minus the 3rd party games, as bad as Nintendo's was they still had better games than the other two taking those two things into consideration.



Pavolink on 07 July 2015
S.Peelman said:
Lol, I came here expecting Nintendo to lose this big time, but 5%, that's a massacre right there. Can't really say I was with Nintendo this E3 either. It was painfully bad.

The treehouse and the NWC for this year remain cool additions though, but they're supposed to be just that, additions to an amazing main conference. Sadly the main event was just not there.

It's better for us to just ignore it and imagine they never made a direct...

 

Can't wait for their E3 Direct! It must be announced soon!



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


DerNebel on 07 July 2015
_Jameson said:
DerNebel said:

Believe me, if we're talking about what is going to be relevant this holiday season then you can pretty much scratch anything but Halo from the Xbox list as well, maybe Forza because it hits a certain audience.

Tomb Raider will sell 1-2m minimal with potential for more, which will still out sell a hand full of does games on that list.

Tomb Raider will be massacred this holiday season. Releasing the same day as Fallout 4 and one week before Battlefront? Good luck with that.

Sure the game can get to a million, but in the big picture of this holiday season it's looking to be pretty much irrelevant.



DerNebel on 07 July 2015
Dulfite said:
Minus the 2016-2018 games, and minus the 3rd party games, as bad as Nintendo's was they still had better games than the other two taking those two things into consideration.

Minus everything that wasn't a new IP and everything that wasn't revealed with gameplay Sony absolutely crushed the other conferences taking those two things into consideration.

Making up special rules to have my team win is fun.



Around the Network
_Jameson on 07 July 2015
Aerys said:
_Jameson said:


I'm not debating quality, there's obviouly a ton of great games for ps4 players to play. but that list is overvaluing a ton of titles that won't be relevant this hoildays. 


If you are talking about sales, dont worry, Sony has the most relevant deals ( Star Wars, COD, AC, ... ) , we saw how deals make the difference with Destiny ( and COD+AC for One)


I actually think that's the most interesting thing going on this holiday season, if PS4 can win in USA this holiday with NO BIG AAA exclusives.



JRPGfan on 07 July 2015
Aerys said:
_Jameson said:

I'm not debating quality, there's obviouly a ton of great games for ps4 players to play. but that list is overvaluing a ton of titles that won't be relevant this hoildays. 


If you are talking about sales, dont worry, Sony has the most relevant deals ( Star Wars, COD, AC, ... ) , we saw how deals make the difference with Destiny ( and COD+AC for One)


Sometimes they dont though.

Witcher 3 and xbox, and look how that turned out.



Hynad on 07 July 2015
_Jameson said:
Hynad said:
_Jameson said:


I'm not debating quality, there's obviouly a ton of great games for ps4 players to play. but that list is overvaluing a ton of titles that won't be relevant this hoildays. 


So the only games in a given library that we should ever count are blockbuster games? Do I get you right?

 

when it comes to holiday console sells, yes.


I see... So Microsoft won E3 because it has chances to win the holiday 2015. I don't see how the two are related, but ok.



_Jameson on 07 July 2015
Hynad said:
_Jameson said:
Hynad said:
_Jameson said:


I'm not debating quality, there's obviouly a ton of great games for ps4 players to play. but that list is overvaluing a ton of titles that won't be relevant this hoildays. 


So the only games in a given library that we should ever count are blockbuster games? Do I get you right?

 

when it comes to holiday console sells, yes.


I see... So it doesn't matter if a library is diverse. All that counts is whether or not a game has a high budget and sells a lot. The quality of the games is irrelevent.  OK...

If I didn't make it clear sorry, I don't want to debate individuals preferences or quality . I'm debating what will help sell more consoles short term(hoilday season)



S.Peelman on 07 July 2015
Pavolink said:
S.Peelman said:
Lol, I came here expecting Nintendo to lose this big time, but 5%, that's a massacre right there. Can't really say I was with Nintendo this E3 either. It was painfully bad.

The treehouse and the NWC for this year remain cool additions though, but they're supposed to be just that, additions to an amazing main conference. Sadly the main event was just not there.

It's better for us to just ignore it and imagine they never made a direct...

 

Can't wait for their E3 Direct! It must be announced soon!

I hear they'll have Twilight Princess HD footage .