By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - (US ONLY) Will Halo 5: Guardians be the game that puts Xbone and PS4 to neck & neck?

 

Will Xbone Get The Glory?

Yes 57 17.43%
 
No 243 74.31%
 
Halo for Wii U!!! XD 27 8.26%
 
Total:327
Aura7541 said:
All hail the mighty Shadow1980!!



OT: The ship has already sailed for the XBO. Even a huge series like Halo can only offer the system a temporary boost. Also, kyser73's comment on GAF is worth a read: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=160467736&postcount=99

How was the thread not locked after that post. There is nothing else that could be added after that.



It takes genuine talent to see greatness in yourself despite your absence of genuine talent.

Around the Network
eva01beserk said:
Aura7541 said:
All hail the mighty Shadow1980!!



OT: The ship has already sailed for the XBO. Even a huge series like Halo can only offer the system a temporary boost. Also, kyser73's comment on GAF is worth a read: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=160467736&postcount=99

How was the thread not locked after that post. There is nothing else that could be added after that.

Haven't done many threads. Can I manually lock it. That was basically the nail in the coffin there.



Ljink96 said:
eva01beserk said:

How was the thread not locked after that post. There is nothing else that could be added after that.

Haven't done many threads. Can I manually lock it. That was basically the nail in the coffin there.

I think he was referring to the thread on GAF.



Versus_Evil said:
Slade6alpha said:
Only way that would happen is if:
1) Sony stops production of the PS4 entirely.
2) Tells consumers to fuck off and buy an Xbox One.
3) 3rd party evaporates and all other games stop coming out for the PS4.

And it will still outsell the xo :3. Gens over for MS and probably the xbox brand in general. The only thing ms can do now is bundle life vests.

Fuck them, I want them kiddy floaties  

Snacks too would be nice. 



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

Shadow1980 said:

No chance in hell Halo 5 is going to turn things around for the XBO. Rare is the individual game that actually makes such a huge impact on a system's fortunes. You can count on one hand the amount of games that made that big of a difference. I can maybe think of only four games made in the past 30 years: Super Mario Bros. (arguably helped get the NES in homes), Sonic the Hedgehog (the first truly big killer app for the Genesis; likely helped boost sales once Nintendo lost their monopoly), Final Fantasy VII (marked the point where the PS1 finally started outselling the N64 in the U.S.), and Halo CE (was to the Xbox like what SMB was to the NES; based on NPD data, by the end of Q1 2002 Halo had an attach rate of over 50% in the U.S.). Nothing else could be argued to be that significant, that big of a killer app than those four games. Nothing else comes close. And three of those were games that helped put a console brand on the map, while only one of them, FFVII, actually caused a system with less-than-great sales to actually start selling well (the PS1 was literally selling at GameCube levels in the U.S. before September '97; it sold just shy of 2 million units in all of 1996 according to NPD). Nearly all other system-sellers have provided a boost that lasted only a month at best (the combination of MKWii and Brawl appears to have given the Wii a decent boost to sales for several months, but not any longer, and the system was already huge beforehand). I mean, let's look at monthly sales of the 360 in the U.S. since it launched:

Halo 3 did provide an unambiguous boost to sales, more than any other game released outside the holidays. Yet both it and a price cut boosted it to only 528k. The combination of Black Ops and Kinect gave a YoY boost for November '10 that may have been beyond the boost provided by the 360S, Gears 3 may have been what caused average weekly sales for September '11 to be higher than the previous month, and Skyrim & MW3 also may be responsible for the YoY boost for November '11. Other than that, there were no clearly major system-sellers for the 360 in the U.S., not even the other Halo games (most people interested in Halo probably already had a 360 by time Reach came out). The biggest boosters for 360 sales were price cuts and the release of the 360S, not individual games.

Halo 5 could boost XBO sales above those of the PS4 in October (depends on when the PS4 gets a price cut and how big it is), but it's not going to do much of anything beyond that. It is not going to be a game-changer like FFVII was for the PS1. End of story.


I agree with almost everything except for the part about no other game having the impact as the 4 games mentioned. Pokémon definitely fits that as well as Tetris, perhaps even Nintendogs, Wii Sports & Brain Age.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

Around the Network
Shadow1980 said:
zorg1000 said:


I agree with almost everything except for the part about no other game having the impact as the 4 games mentioned. Pokémon definitely fits that as well as Tetris, perhaps even Nintendogs, Wii Sports & Brain Age.

Well, I was thinking home consoles, but yeah, Tetris and Pokemon were definitely huge. Tetris was the killer app at launch for the Game Boy, and while the system sold well throughout the 90s it reached far greater heights after Pokemon debuted. I'm not sure about the impacts of those other games on DS sales, though. I'd have to go look through the sales figures and see, but it seems that the DS really took off after the DS Lite came out.

DS was probably a combination of things, DS Lite+Brain Age+Nintendogs+New Super Mario Bros+Mario Kart DS+Animal Crossing all within roughly a year was probably huge for the system.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

celador said:
If it is reviewed well it could turn the whole console sales race around.


Just like halo and halo 2 did for Xbox 



 

mM
Shadow1980 said:
super6646 said:

It'll give it a huge sales increase, but it won't single handedly do the job. I do think the XB1 will eventually re-take the US and UK, WW is a sure thing for PS4.

How so? The PS4 is still winning even though it's now the more expensive system. Even after aggressive discounting the XBO is down almost 7% YoY. The reduction to $350 gave it a solid boost for the holidays, but that completely petered out afterwards. Meanwhile, the PS4 hasn't even gotten its first price cut yet. Once it does (and if history is any indication it'll get a $100 cut this year), sales should skyrocket. The only chance the XBO has of winning this generation is via a price cut that drops it to $100 less than the PS4, and even then there's no guarantees (being $50 cheaper isn't helping). However, I don't think MS wants to risk cutting the XBO's price to $200 in the face of a $300 PS4. The losses could end up being unacceptable. Even if it did when, it'd be a Pyrrhic victory as the losses sustained from too deep of a price cut too soon could seriously damage the prospects of Xbox continuing to be a thing after this generation. I think they'd rather take the loss sales-wise in the U.S. and make some profit than win the U.S. but have the system be a net loser money-wise over the course of the generation.


Concur with the bolded statement, Shadow. Shareholders and investors will not be pleased. Furthermore, losing more money shouldn't be the option, even if Microsoft has 'infinite' financials.



" It has never been about acknowledgement when you achieve something. When you are acknowledged, then and only then can you achieve something. Always have your friends first to achieve your goals later." - OnlyForDisplay

Samus Aran said:
MS should try to make a new IP that can reach Halo status.


Indeed. Hopefully E3 brings some explosive reactions similar to what Halo did at E3 2001 (not sure if that was the year for the trailer, so someone please correct if incorrect).



" It has never been about acknowledgement when you achieve something. When you are acknowledged, then and only then can you achieve something. Always have your friends first to achieve your goals later." - OnlyForDisplay

Shadow1980 said:

How so? The PS4 is still winning even though it's now the more expensive system. Even after aggressive discounting the XBO is down almost 7% YoY. The reduction to $350 gave it a solid boost for the holidays, but that completely petered out afterwards. Meanwhile, the PS4 hasn't even gotten its first price cut yet. Once it does (and if history is any indication it'll get a $100 cut this year), sales should skyrocket. The only chance the XBO has of winning this generation is via a price cut that drops it to $100 less than the PS4, and even then there's no guarantees (being $50 cheaper isn't helping). However, I don't think MS wants to risk cutting the XBO's price to $200 in the face of a $300 PS4. The losses could end up being unacceptable. Even if it did when, it'd be a Pyrrhic victory as the losses sustained from too deep of a price cut too soon could seriously damage the prospects of Xbox continuing to be a thing after this generation. I think they'd rather take the loss sales-wise in the U.S. and make some profit than win the U.S. but have the system be a net loser money-wise over the course of the generation.

I would also like to add that the PS4 actually beat the XBO in the UK for the holiday season. The XBO outsold the PS4 in November, but the PS4 outsold the XBO by a greater amount in December. The XBO's best chance to win a country is the US, but as you said, it's going to be extremely costly to the point that it won't be worth it.