I watched it live back then and liked it so much, I bought the DVD.  I was engaged through the whole thing!  Even tho Booker lost, I was on the edge of my seat through the whole match--especially when he did that Harlem Hangover off the top rope!  

But hey, we all have opinions.  I just regareded WM19 as the last great Wrestlemanias before the Cena era.  First time I heard somebody not liking it.

I think the reason for me not liking it, is my first live wrestlemania was the 18...and that just blew my mind. I went back and watched others. 

HHH vs Sting will be awesome!!! Why is nobody hyped? :P

I don't hate Reigns. I think he could be good, but he doesn't feel ready yet. Also, WWE has built Lesnar into this unbeatable beast that it feels wrong that Reigns could beat him. I'd rather see Rollins cash in on Lesnar.

I'm honestly still shocked they didn't pull the trigger on Sting/Undertaker, this was probably their only year to do it.

The beginning of the ladder match was really slow but it really picked up. I still don't know what was the point of R-Truth.

Well. loved the finish to that match and...

The eventual Bryan/Ziggler feud  

O.My. Lanta. WHAT an ending to that Orton/Rollins match. 

Edit: Just when you think HHH's ego couldn't get any bigger, he rises to the occasion. 

Edit (2)- Well I was wrong about HHH and Sting... match was a lot of fun. 

Did Sting just lose...

Not enough that he lost, they had to bury him and his accomplishments on commentary as well.