I have to agree with twesterm, Subspace Emissary on it's own, is fundimentally broken. The camera is just awful for one. Sometimes it follows you, other times it goes on it's own and you soon find yourself off screen. That's not too bad if it's just scrolling left to right, but it's death when you're going through tunnels that run vertically and horizontally and you have no idea if you're hitting a wall or what and the camera is panning diagonally.
Playing co-op is even worse. Expect the 2nd player to be off-screen 30-50% of the time and die needlessly quite a few times throughout the game.
SE is a side thing so we can't be too harsh on it, but if it was game by itself it'd get a 4 for gameplay. Everything else is totally awesome though, especially the cinematics.