The both look amazing, but I'm slightly more interested in Batman: Arkham Knight.

Batman for me. I was really excited to play Witcher 2 but I ended up not really enjoying it and quitting about 5 or so hours in. I may still give Witcher 3 a try but idk yet. I liked Arkham Asylum and loved Arkham City, however, and the gameplay of Arkham knight looks fantastic.

I will try to get both, but can't get either at launch. Have a low game budget this year.

I'll get both day one probably

I'm not but I'm considering getting one this year.  Final fantasy 15, Fable Legends are top of the list. 

i saw you say you weren't going to get bloodborne multiple times, but it looks amazing. Hopefully they have a demo for it so people who are on the fence can try it out

Yeah I'm not getting Bloodborne but I hope it does good.  These unique titles are needed.  My unique genre would be cinematic titles like the order or games like heavy rain. 

Both.

The Witcher 3 as they are rarer and are full of humor. The dwarfs are great.

I'm getting both too but I think Witcher 3 will be the longer lasting and more fun game for me personally

I've played the first two Batman games and I found them ok but not great.

I've played the first two The Witcher and I loved them.

Do I have to say more?