| Lucas-Rio said:
I don't want Pokemon to look like Xenoblade, it would totally lost the tone of the game, its identity, its design and would take more than 5 years to create for diminishing returns as it would lost a lot of appeal.
Xenoblade was a true masterpiece, but it has absolutely nothing in common with Pokemon. Pokemon will look better,, but it absolutely does not need the scale of Xenoblade, nor the full 3D view and the more realistics models.
|
I guarantee you that Pokemon has access to more devs than Monolith does. I'm sure I've read somewhere that XY had the biggest dev team of any Nintendo game so far. They could make team big enough to pump the games out in a timely matter, just like Ubisoft does with big games like AssCreed.
It wouldn't lose it's tone or identity at all. There are already scenes that look like this:

All the game I describe to you does is make this gameplay through out the game, instead of a just cutscene. (and make the environments not look like N64 garbage) The game would still be cel-shaded and still have Pokemon's "tone." It would just be in a full, modeled to scale world. If anything, the top down 2D games are suffering from diminishing returns. Making a Pokemon game that always looks like what is shown above would be monumental, revolutionary even, to the presentation and the world of Pokemon games. It would be as big as OoT was to Zelda, Mario 64 was to Mario, Prime was to Metroid, and 7 was to Final Fantasy.
Xenoblade does have something in common with Pokemon. They are both large scale JRPGs where you travel the world to complete a linear story. Only, Xenoblade Chronicles represents where large scale JRPGs are now, while Pokemon XY still is, in many ways, like a large JRPG made 20 years ago, only prettier. Before Xenoblade 3D, you could blame it on the hardware. After it, you just won't be able to.
The actual game would look like this:




...rather than it just being relegated to concept art and ingame cutscenes. That is still very Pokemon in every way, and there's no good reason why the next Pokemon game on the next Nintendo handheld should not look like that with all the scale that these images imply. It absolutely does need the scale, 3D view, and "realistic" (I'd rather call it life-sized) models of Xenoblade.