Digital Foundry on Red Dead Redemption:

'In Red Dead Redemption, this effect is gone or at least massively reduced, meaning that the gulf in picture quality between the two versions is more readily pronounced. There's no doubt about it: just in terms of the basic aspects of the image, there's little doubt that the 360 version presents more resolution and more detail, and this is rather more important than it would be in many other games.'

But on THIS game. 'It doesn't make much difference'

I'm waiting for the day when "realistic water" doesn't matter.

Just look at the gulf between how DF compared 360 and PS3 games to how they compare them now:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-red-dead-redemption-face-off

This gen oly console warz matters. Nothing else
It's time for a real war again, so we stop batteling over consoles

but if all that don't matter why does broken driveclub online matter or buggy single player in LBP3? You can add MCC broken online, AC & COD yearly repetiveness to the don't matter list either. Such double standards in this industry! 

The grass in xenoblade does the same. For those who brought it up.

Yes! Just what GTA gameplay needed! More grass!

It's going to be rough going for Microsoft from here on out.

I think it all matters!  however I must point out online issues are usually much more temporary than the inherent advantages of having a more powerful console.  Also only some reviewers have mentioned LBP3 bugs and they're pretty small judging from review videos so most likely not a big deal.  MCC has been ok from when i've played online at a friends but I suppose that's pretty limited

It's confirmed then: The PS4 isn't powerful enough to handle lawnmowers, while the Xbox One is!