I'd say 93.

Yes.

http://www.co-optimus.com/game/3476/xbox-one/halo-the-master-chief-collection.html

You didn't look hard enough lol this site is all about co-op.

I think I did my prediction on the Xbox Empire thread, but I said 93

97

Game of the Generation (so far)

Orange box got 96 on meta, so I believe MCC will have a similar score. The sheer value of the pack is incredible. It deserves to score and sell well imho

95, they're the best FPS ever

I actually think 95 is possible, even though I know how hard that is for games these days. But this is just too amazing of a collection with countless achievements, multiplayer maps, upgrades, and fan service. Honestly, Halo 4's inclusion might be the only thing that brings the meta down.

Hard to say. Collections almost always score very well, but they seem to hit a road block around the 90 mark. Unlike stuff like TLOU:R, which was treated in a similar fashion to a cross gen release (which is fair enough, it was essentially just a late port after all), collections are treated as raw value propositions. That works mostly in their favor of course, and is why they tend to score well, but there are limits to how far value can push old content.

I think a lot will come down to the quality of H2's remake, and how generous the reviewers are feeling. 93 seems like a safe bet, but it has a moderate chance of hitting 95+.

I think so, too, and perhaps also on the other new content, the Halo 5 beta, whatever we will see from it. This gen reviewers seem to factor "value" in quite large in their reviews so I guess above 90 could very well happen.

93!