By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The Art of #GamerGate

DanneSandin said:

And you're proving them right. That's the point. What I'm saying is that it's better the change the name of the movement than to be ascosiated with misogynistic assholes, isn't it? GamerGate is now very closely ascosiated with that kind of treatment of women, so it's better to move on and change the name of the game. Even from the very start GG got ties with harassments and death threats.

And would you mind giving me links to the articles you were talking about with regards to gamers and such? The attack on gaming culture? Thx =)

How am I proving them right exactly, that doesn't make any sense? Am I a psychopath for suggesting that generalizing a group as a few bad actions is not reasonable?

Question 1: Who associated GamerGate with that kind of treatment of women. Various members of the group seemed to be doing different things. While some of them sent death threats, other where trying to be polite and supporting women in gaming, but why is it that only one side, the bad side, defines what Gamer Gate is?

Question 2: How will changing the name, make anything better? The point is to generalizing anything even suggesting the media might be unethical as anti-feminist. This as already happened in some degree with the #NotMyShield movement. The name is irrelevant.

This is what is supposed to be a professional media industry, where gamers are there main audience, and yet, these articles are generalizing and demonizing the entire community. You wouldn't be happy if you're doctor showed up to work late, in dirty jeans, and without any of his medical devices, why should games jouranlism be any different? Because a few children got mad and sent death threats?

http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/DevinWilson/20140828/224450/A_Guide_to_Ending_quotGamersquot.php

http://kotaku.com/we-might-be-witnessing-the-death-of-an-identity-1628203079

http://www.polygon.com/2014/8/28/6078391/video-games-awful-week

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2014/08/the-death-of-the-gamers-and-the-women-who-killed-them/

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/08/28/it-s-dangerous-to-go-alone-why-are-gamers-so-angry.html

http://dangolding.tumblr.com/post/95985875943/the-end-of-gamers

http://www.vice.com/read/this-guys-embarrassing-relationship-drama-is-killing-the-gamer-identity-828

http://www.buzzfeed.com/josephbernstein/gaming-is-leaving-gamers-behind

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/224400/Gamers_dont_have_to_be_your_audience_Gamers_are_over.php



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

Around the Network
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

Think about what your saying for a minute. You are saying you'd rather the professional gaming media, you know people who get paid to provide gamers with information, provide us with faulty and biased information then children acting up because they are mad. Newsflash, the gaming community aren't professional, they do not follow the same rules as professional organizations.  

Are death threats and harrassment some how ok? No.

Are death threats and harrassment unique to Gamergate? Hell no.

So why in the hell do you think, no Gamergate = No Harrasment, no my friend it means more shitty journalism.

Just because a few psychopaths, sent death threats because of what Zoe did, doesn't mean she wasn't wrong, nor does it me those death threats are right.

But especially in the gaming community, psychopaths send death threats about everything, game not working death threat, game not good enough death threat.

You can't get rid of them because of the way to community's developed and even if you raze it to the ground as this part of the gaming media is trying to do, it won't amount to shit, it'll just be more demonizing. The only ones who would survive, figuratively, would be the psychos making death threats, and then normal people will equate gamer with psychopath, like the mainstream media has been doing for decades.

 

Its a lot more complicated then unethical journalism vs death threats, that should be obvious.

Bolded part kinda shows everything that is wrong about GG: Zoe receives death threats, and you're saying that she isn't wrong, while completely disregarding all the male journalists involved.

I should necver have written in this thread. GG always gets out of hand. But yes, I'd much rather have corrupt journalists than people receiving death threats. And I also think that's why journalists are "attacking" gaming culture; becasue IT is corrupt and rotten. Who the hell sends death threats tro some one over bad scores or bad ending?! Thats fiucking sick. Something IS seriously wrong within gaming culture.



I'm on Twitter @DanneSandin!

Furthermore, I think VGChartz should add a "Like"-button.

Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/DevinWilson/20140828/224450/A_Guide_to_Ending_quotGamersquot.php

http://kotaku.com/we-might-be-witnessing-the-death-of-an-identity-1628203079

http://www.polygon.com/2014/8/28/6078391/video-games-awful-week

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2014/08/the-death-of-the-gamers-and-the-women-who-killed-them/

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/08/28/it-s-dangerous-to-go-alone-why-are-gamers-so-angry.html

http://dangolding.tumblr.com/post/95985875943/the-end-of-gamers

http://www.vice.com/read/this-guys-embarrassing-relationship-drama-is-killing-the-gamer-identity-828

http://www.buzzfeed.com/josephbernstein/gaming-is-leaving-gamers-behind

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/224400/Gamers_dont_have_to_be_your_audience_Gamers_are_over.php


Anyone thinking that these all going live on the same day is simply coincidence, are seriously naive.



Tachikoma said:

Apparently you don't use twitter very often, things were said, multiple times, that not only acted as her getting involved herself, but making it clear that anyone even so much as on the fence, was an angry male and thus "a monster".

again, gamergate started out as, and continues to be about the corruption, the problem is i suspect you have bought in to the bullshit, with all vocal feminists and all games media constantly making the connection where a connection was never there, and pushing their agenda, by subscribing to that train of thought you have robbed yourself of objectivity.

Now for the bolded,
Feminists have been around for an extremely long time, and have done amazing things to aid with equality and bring fairness and stability to society, agressive feminism is a relatively new breed in which educated women (many from communications studies and such vocational degrees) step headlong in to the firing line to lay down their ideals, there is no middle ground, you are either with them or against them, but it isn't simply a matter of "this person doesn't agree with us, but let's hear them out anyway" it's a matter of "theyre the enemy, shame them, attack them, insult them and degrade any point they attempt to make by cherry picking whatever you can and fix-focusing on a particular point, even if they werent the ones that made it, to force your own agenda.

That is the case here, I am neutral to either discussion, becase neither side are approaching things in a way I wish to identify with, however there is an extreme amount of cherry picking going on, a well known feminist will spout absolute tripe for hours, claiming anyone who is so much as undecided is a monster, misogynist and potential rapist, but the second someone speaks up in defence, regardless of how calm or polite they do so, either the person they directed the response to or the droves of mindless followers of said person take it upon themselves to do the attacking and labeling in their stead.

This culture of aggressive insistant opinion is very much aggressive feminism, because there is not so much as a suggestion of any form of open dialog, it's not an invitation to discuss and enrich the situation, it is simply laying down a line in the sand and forcing people to pick a side, and god help you if it isn't the side they wanted you to pick.

I've even had fellow female game developers still in the business talk to me about having received emails and letters from prominent feminists and games sites basically asking "have you heard about gamersgate, what is your view and by the way if you get involved you will be attacked and assaulted by millions of angry men, if that happens we'll defend you", and it's absolutely sickening, i've even had a very well known, and active games journalist who i was previously good friends with, ask me to get involved and help "construct" a situation where I would join a list of victimized women in the industry who have been personally threatened, to make matters even more sickening, It was heavilly implied that in doing so, I would "greatly increase my noteriety and favor within the industry and media".

It's this discussion that lead me to write a long post on my experiences with this corruption a few days ago, and frankly i'm fucking sick it of.

The industry is a cess pit and there is no amecable end in sight, there is no middle ground, no matter which side wins, everything is going to go to shit.

Oh and those zoe nude pictures? they were already all over the internet long before this all blew up, that's kinda what happens when you do a series of softcore porn shoots.

No offense, but this makes me more excited to become a game's developer than even Phil Fish's tweet to quit.

The only thing i'm looking forward to more than industry corruption is my very first death threat. 

:)



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

DanneSandin said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

Think about what your saying for a minute. You are saying you'd rather the professional gaming media, you know people who get paid to provide gamers with information, provide us with faulty and biased information then children acting up because they are mad. Newsflash, the gaming community aren't professional, they do not follow the same rules as professional organizations.  

Are death threats and harrassment some how ok? No.

Are death threats and harrassment unique to Gamergate? Hell no.

So why in the hell do you think, no Gamergate = No Harrasment, no my friend it means more shitty journalism.

Just because a few psychopaths, sent death threats because of what Zoe did, doesn't mean she wasn't wrong, nor does it me those death threats are right.

But especially in the gaming community, psychopaths send death threats about everything, game not working death threat, game not good enough death threat.

You can't get rid of them because of the way to community's developed and even if you raze it to the ground as this part of the gaming media is trying to do, it won't amount to shit, it'll just be more demonizing. The only ones who would survive, figuratively, would be the psychos making death threats, and then normal people will equate gamer with psychopath, like the mainstream media has been doing for decades.

 

Its a lot more complicated then unethical journalism vs death threats, that should be obvious.

Bolded part kinda shows everything that is wrong about GG: Zoe receives death threats, and you're saying that she isn't wrong, while completely disregarding all the male journalists involved.

I should necver have written in this thread. GG always gets out of hand. But yes, I'd much rather have corrupt journalists than people receiving death threats. And I also think that's why journalists are "attacking" gaming culture; becasue IT is corrupt and rotten. Who the hell sends death threats tro some one over bad scores or bad ending?! Thats fiucking sick. Something IS seriously wrong within gaming culture.

Don't respond to anything else, don't cherry pick and bold things, no read the whole thing and answer the two questions at the bottom.

You read the bolded but ignore everything else I said.

You claim I disregarded all the male journalists involved, yet I simply wasn't talking about them, because I was talking about the death threats to Zoe specifically.

READ, I said both what Zoe did and those who sent death threats, were wrong. I did not say the male journalists involved get a pass, the are also wrong to.

Pay attention and Answer this simple question?

Do you have an intrest in playing video games? Yes/No

Have you sent a death threat to a developer/publisher/games media outlet because of something you didn't like? Yes/No

Don't respond to anything else, don't cherry pick and bold things, no read the whole thing and answer the two questions.



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

Around the Network

Controversy on Twitter? Big fucking deal. Saw the main woman that is speaking out on Colbert and she had a tough time when he said there were plenty of games for girls to play that don't portray women as helpless victims. She was like... well yeah... but those other games that don't show women in a good light....  That is where it seemed to fall apart for her.  Now if every single damn game was like this then she might have a point.  Colbert should have just told her to go play Super Princess Peach and shut the fuck up.

As for the other part of it (death threats against that woman who made that depressing game)... Who cares?  It is the internet and there are plenty of stupid fucks that act all tough or make death threats.  Only problem is almost any stupid fuck in USA can buy a gun and that supposedly makes them Billy Badass when without it they would get their ass kicked.



DanneSandin said:

Bolded part kinda shows everything that is wrong about GG: Zoe receives death threats, and you're saying that she isn't wrong, while completely disregarding all the male journalists involved.

I should necver have written in this thread. GG always gets out of hand. But yes, I'd much rather have corrupt journalists than people receiving death threats. And I also think that's why journalists are "attacking" gaming culture; becasue IT is corrupt and rotten. Who the hell sends death threats tro some one over bad scores or bad ending?! Thats fiucking sick. Something IS seriously wrong within gaming culture.

This works entirely on the assumption that the death threat held any water at all, and wasn't just an idle empty parade, like pretty much every other online threat. The police themselves stated that they did not believe the threat posed any actual risk.

Get good at a multiplayer game, or cheat, and you'll get the occasional insult, get REALLY good and you'll occasionally get a really irate player saying he'll come over to where you live and kill you, but these are idle threats, and just an extension of playing out their emotions in an environment where anonymity allows them to exaggerate every portion of their being, his isn't exclusive to gamers nor is it exclusive to men.

If course, if you'd like to link to any news or any reports of anyone actually following through on these threats, THEN we've got a discussion, until then it's just an empty guesture, exaggerated by the anonymity of internet.

This problem with using these threats in the way they are doing, is that you're associating the freedom and relative saftey of an online anonymouse platform with real world violence and aggression, when it simply isn't the case for 99.99% of people.

If the person is actually willing to go through with a threat, then that person clearly has issues that predate the entire discussion.



RolStoppable said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

You claim I disregarded all the male journalists involved, yet I simply wasn't talking about them, because I was talking about the death threats to Zoe specifically.

Is there a reason to believe that all the death threats were legitimate? I don't mean in the sense that people would drive to Zoe's house and get the job done, but that the people who posted the threats are indeed gamers and not some shills.

I have often thought about it, especially with the situation i encountered a few weeks ago where a prominent media editor was suggesting basically making one up and offering me fame and noteriety in return.

It does beg the question whether these claims are all actually legitimate or if they're simply manufacturered to further their cause / push an agenda.

But as i said in my last post, even if the "threat" was genuinely sent by an actual gamer, an email message from a disgruntled internet user is a far cry from actually following through with said threat.

Also, i'm hating this linking of death threats to gamers as being some sort of proof that gamers are inherantly bad, because it happens in any job dependant upon a position of fame or power, sports players, actors, entertainers, comedians, law enforcement and company executives all receive death threats from time to time, the difference is for them it's a much more personal experience because theres a certain degree of disconnect between them and the general public.

"omg someone sent me an email / twitter message saying watch your back" is just facepalm worthy paranoia



RolStoppable said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

You claim I disregarded all the male journalists involved, yet I simply wasn't talking about them, because I was talking about the death threats to Zoe specifically.

Is there a reason to believe that all the death threats were legitimate? I don't mean in the sense that people would drive to Zoe's house and get the job done, but that the people who posted the threats are indeed gamers and not some shills.

I don't think there is any way to prove their legitamacy, all I assume we do know is that they were made. But honestly I think that is irrelevant. I'm a 20 something year old male, yet I don't fantasize about school shootings, I'm black yet I've never been to prison, I'm a gamer but I've never sent a death threat, or even a letter to devs publishers or reviewers. 

Why am I suddently part of a sick culture of sending death threats because I don't like a thing? How come I'm not simply a gamer because I like to play video games?



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

tagged. i will watch it later