By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Clearly this thread is in dire thread of a Kantor.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

Around the Network
outlawauron said:
Clearly this thread is in dire thread of a Kantor.

Why is that?



theprof00 said:

Also
@MR KHAN
I asked you a to back up your case against me and you have yet to respond.
I asked you to provide evidence in posts of my divisiveness and strife causing.
Please resopnd to a simple request to provide evidence.

Also

unvote Hylian
Vote Outlaw

 

The votes speak for themselves, i think. You appointing yourself high inquisitor seems to have made you more trouble than just me.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

That is the flimsiest argument ive ever read. Ive now asked you twice to back up your claims of divisiveness. Lets see some proof. Otherwise you're a fabricator of evidence, and a fabricator with intent to lynch no less



I have three votes on me.
one is for calling someone a noob.
another by yourself using unproven rhetoric and evidence
and another by a person who refuses to listen to reason despite being proven scientifically that at least one reason iscomplete garbage

Yeah, great basis for that supporting reason khan



Around the Network

Honestly tho, its not my ass. People are going to look directly at you and nickels do my mislynch.
Both your arguments are flawed and illogical and lacking in any evidence.
prepare yourself for a lynch tomorrow



Conegamer said:
Sparks said:

Conegamer said:

 Yes, I saw what you said. Just because a couple of people have voted for me it doesn't mean it becomes a one-on-one, particularly on the first day. If there's other people who you believe are more suspicious, why not vote for them? Surely you have reasons to vote for them, right? Perhaps you could provide them.

I already gave many reasons for the people I suspect; IkePoR, RCTjunkie, outlawauron, and to a much lesser extent Khan, you, and Smeags. But it didn't work. I also asked people who are currently voting for prof to reconsider, but that didn't work either.

Now I have to think practically, and try for the least amount of losses. I can't let town hand prof's head to the mafia on a silver platter (our best townie), not even wasting their kill for the night, and leaving them free to get more people.

I trust prof frequents the thread enough to save himself in time before nightfall if need be.

Having said all that, I think I have one last chance to sway one person, since I only just read his post, and he seems to have misunderstood QUITE a lot of things.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6562258

I'm busy IRL at the moment, though, so it will have to wait. Have fun in the meantime ; )

That is fine, you raise some good points.

At any rate, may as well make my vote now and explain a little now with a more in-depth explanation tomorrow or later today. I vote Outlawauron. 

 

Why? A few reasons. It is mainly due to the responses in the thread of which he has made thus far. First let's have a look at Smeags' and now also TheProf's comparisons (there's more from both of these users, but you get the idea). Both of them reflect the same thing; Outlaw is the only person whose contributions appear to have gone backwards as time went by. Now, that's unusual because more and more accusations have been thrown out and things have got more serious, so a lack of discussion and content appears to me to be an evasive move.

Then you have comments like this one, where he effectively tries to find a reason to not respond to questions which is something that doesn't make sense to me. Indeed, as time went on his opinion and his contributions seemed to boil down further to a point where they were unrelated to the game, as he seemed to almost fall behind a false persona thereafter and make more general comments. To me, this strikes as a man who is trying to remain in the shadows and banking on an earlier flurry of activity (which upon reflection seems rather canned and pre-planned, as others picked up on sooner but my lack of experience took longer to pick up on) to protect himself when we get to the serious part of the day. Again, this reflects back to what was mentioned before.

Wright still unnerves me somewhat. But, I've spoken to him enough on and off the site to know that this is just his style, at least that's what I'm thinking for now. It's why I wanted to wait for more information but theprof's comparison saved me looking through it tomorrow morning, so it just tipped it in his favour enough to make my decision. 

As I said I'll go into more depth when I have more time. But Outlaw seems to be trying his best to just tip-toe his way around and has made a few slip-ups which are unbecoming of him. So, out of everything I've seen thus far, I'm going to have to accuse him. 

You read prof's chart? My contributions have increased slightly before/after. That's how I read it at least. Your comprehension on my first quoted post is severely lacking as I'm clearly talking about rules of the game, not any questions period. The second quoted post was a literal answer to a question, and helped me understand some personality behind the name. I don't see how I'm slipping up and tip toeing, whereas you attribute Wright's posting (my finger is still pointed at you Wrong) to a style of play. It's aggravating and a double standard.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

theprof00 said:
outlawauron said:
Clearly this thread is in dire thread of a Kantor.

Why is that?

It was a tongue in cheek comment about him being the unofficial VGC detective. I was in the process of replying with my post above to explain what I believe to be shoddy detective work.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

Will add that Cone is either working with Wright or his rl bromance is clouding his vision.

Haven't decided yet...



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

theprof00 said:

lot to go over in this post so I'll bullet for easier reading.
1. There's plenty of ways to enjoy the theme without vapidity. Some games people use quotes from the source under their posts. Other games, people talk in character. Sometimes people use references as their metaphors. But one thing is certain. We are in a game where we were never told we couldn't name our characters. We were also told that mafia have names, and also additional fake-names they can use. We were also told that faction alignment means nothing, and that characters don't match night actions. What is the result? People hinting at their characters names. What's the point? Sure it's fun to play your character....the point is why is everyone only "hinting" at their character? Why are people making post after post about something so inconsequential?

2. At this point I wrote a few paragraphs but realized that your accusations are completely baseless, so instead insert a line about steel swords if you will.

3. Perhaps I said that flavor conversations are bad for town, but perhaps that's too harsh. Flavor is fine....in moderation. If all I see out of one person is all flavor, then that looks bad.

4. Tell me in what way the flavor has pushed forward anything? It's a fun side-quest. Nothing more. In fact, the only reason you are having a somewhat contributory debate is because I'm here.

5. Look, I'm not telling you what to do. Do whatever you want. Just...for the record, I don't think you're mafia. It would be far too stupid to pick a fight with me on day 1 if you were. And your shameless flipflopping on activity vs inactivity is begging for votes.

In fact, I'm going to make a quick tally of all the inconsistencies you've said. Feel free to do the same for me, if you choose. cont next post.

It's simple really. The thing about inactivity vs activity was because I wanted more people's input. My initial intuition was that you seemed suspicious, for the reasons I've said. Someone already tallied up the activity and you're the most active by a landslide, with almost no flavor posts, almost all accusations. But others, including yourself, voiced that inactivity was the suspicious thing, so I decided that since I'm inexperienced, there might be something to it I'm missing, so I decided to ask for the logic behind that. I was basically asking you for your defense without addressing you directly, because after all, you weren't the only active one, just the most active one. But really, the question was for you. And you answered it. You have nothing. I was waiting because I'm new to this and was hoping for some insight from more experienced players. What insight did I get? Well, your insight was that I should have a backbone. So I will. My initial opinion, before I began to doubt myself, was that you were suspicious. I doubted myself because of inexperience, but this experience this game requires isn't necessarily with the game itself, just with reading people and putting two and two together, which I can do just fine.

I've regained my confidence. I think you're scum. Nolan was probably your fake claim. Also your posts are long, distracting, and I agree with some of what other people have said that your excessive activity has given too many people a chance to hide as well as draw attention to only what you want attention drawn to. And your playstyle just pisses me off. I've said it before, all the rhetoric and semantics, so annoying. This isn't an Ace Attorney themed mafia game. I definitely think you're scum, but even if you're not scum, you're bad for the town, and you're kind of ruining the fun for me.

 

Vote for theprof00

 

Sorry guys, I was too busy to check in yesterday. There's way too much to respond to now, so give me a bit to process all this.