Ok, this is what started all this. 

• You put up an image of a supersampled game. A very supersampled game. Say its equivalent to 480p with AA and that its ok for you. I just pointed out that if you were to really try and make a 480p image look that sharp you would either need to also use supersampling which is expensive or use an amount of AA that is more expensive than just upping teh resolution. Which means the point you were trying to make with that image is misleading or redundant.
• You dabble in this again and say most games will be ok at just 576p with AA. Again, i said all that to explain to you that adding enough AA to a low rez image to make it look as good as the image you put up is too expensive.
• Then you talking about prefering higher rez with loer poly count and use a 3ds/vita as refernce. Those platforms peak at a 5" screen. What looks ok on such a screen will look horrible if you blow it up to fit 32"+ screens. If making games for a bigger screen, that will have bigger images, you need more than what you are saying you would prefer. 
• Then you talk about your opinions or how games today are crap and you prefer the older stuff, which I was saying, has nothing to do with this thread.

All I did was answer the things you talked about, and explained why they are important. But lets just agree to disagree. Maybe we don't just get eachother, nothing wrong there.

You are evading the question while throwing absolutons around. My question has an actual answer. You just can't answer it cause it will make the point you are trying make void. 

Yet you are throwing around generalizations like "majority of people"" ultimately all that matters" "no one"...etc. But when presented with situations that dispute your claims you just dismiss them.

Personally, I tend to think that what makes a game sell is marketing and graphics. At least initially, what makes people keep playing it is if its fun, which in turn will spur word of mouth and then more sales. Then the next game from that IP would be bought cause people believe the last one was good.

And again with your minecraft and mobile game reference; every heard the saying "in the land of the blind the one eyed man is king"?

I played BF4 on PS3 and X1. The X1 version has sharper textures, better lighting, significantly less pop in, etc. Also, the 8th gen versions look less impressive when you only see them running at 30 fps.

I suggest you go look at screen shots comparing the 7th gen versions to the 8th gen versions. You don't need 1080p to see the differences.

Yeah but that game isn't saturating 720p on the X1.  Games like Infamous Second son do.

I honestly don't know what you're saying here.