By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Unofficial Sony Vs MS E3

 

E3?

Microsoft? 101 32.48%
 
Sony? 209 67.20%
 
Total:310
Dr.Henry_Killinger on 10 June 2014
curl-6 said:
This site has vastly more Sony than MS supporters, a poll has only one possible outcome.

This thread is unofficial ofc.

MS will probably win in the scoring section if Nintendo doesn't deliver because cause CGI doesn't dock you points. Strangely, I don't think they mentioned anything new going on with the platform or the system.

While Sony announced Exclusive Betas, New Bundles, PlayStation TV in the states, Youtube Share, Camera Jab (lol), Morpheus, and Now.

MS played it safe which was why I scored it as average, the general media agrees with me. Probably because of last years loss. Especially the Halo "demo", they demoed the multiplayer of Master Cheif collection but showed pure CGI for Halo 5. IDK how you can be complain about UC4 CGI and not about Halo 5 CGI.

Sony took more risk and showed more gameplay, e.g they showed a better FC4 trailer than Ubisoft did for their own show, but also took more risk and spent 20 minutes shooting themselves in the foot. I had them at an 8-9 before it hit and that part dropped their conference down to a 4-5 for me. The tech and games they showed afterward pulled it up to 7.5 like microsoft, but that additional point was because they had gameplay of things releasing this year.



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

Around the Network
Zekkyou on 10 June 2014
MoHasanie said:
Sony had the better exclusives but MS had the much better conference.

Pretty much how i feel too.



zumnupy10 on 10 June 2014

Sony showed less games overall. But their games are more interesting.

Uncharted 4 , Bloodbourne , The Order , LBP3 , TLuU >>>>>>> Halo collection, Sunset Overdrive, ScaleBound and Phantom Dust remake.



Fusioncode on 10 June 2014

Sony showed off more exclusive games that I'm interested in. Only XBO games I want right now are Crackdown 3 and Sunset Overdrive. I prefer Sony's E3.



Sigs are dumb. And so are you!

jlmurph2 on 10 June 2014
TheBoneCollector said:
Sony had way more gameplay and exclusive focused:

Uncharted 4
Little big planet 3
The order
Blood borne (GAme of the show imo)
No mans sky
Grim Fandango
TLOU remaster
MAgicka 2

All exclusive.

Exclusives

Happy Wars *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Crackdown

Sunset overdrive *Gameplay* 2014

Project spark *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Scalebound

Super ultra mega double deluxe platinum extreme makeover Dead Rising 3 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo 5: Guardians

Killer instinct Season 2 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo Master Chief Edition *Gameplay* 2014

Phantom Dust

Forza Horizon 2 2014

Fable legends *Gameplay* Beta 2014

Ori and the Blind Forest *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Inside *Gameplay Trailer* 2014



Around the Network
jlmurph2 on 10 June 2014
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:

Here is the stack up

I say MS (7.5) vs Sony (7.6)

MS: 

~90 minutes 

Just Games

20 games

A lot of Multiplats

A lot of CGI

The Conference was really focus, excellent production much better camera work and presentation then Sony, but the conference felt safe. Multiplats dominated the conference and ACU and Witcher were probably the only multiplat I remembered seeing gameplay. Sunset Overdrive was the only AAA exclusive i remember having gameplay.

Sony:

~2 hours

Games + Vita + Vita TV + PS Now + TV/Movies + PS4 Share + Indies

19 Games

A lot of exclusives

Gameplay focus

Bad Camera/Audio

The 20 Minutes of the TV/Music nearly destroyed the conference but they managed to pull it back with games again. 

EDIT: On second thought expectations were disproportionate, MS having high expectations and Sony having low expectations, this might color some people's views but that didn't have much of an effect in my evaluations.


refer to post above, you obviously don't remember MS' show



Dr.Henry_Killinger on 10 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:
TheBoneCollector said:
Sony had way more gameplay and exclusive focused:

Uncharted 4
Little big planet 3
The order
Blood borne (GAme of the show imo)
No mans sky
Grim Fandango
TLOU remaster
MAgicka 2

All exclusive.

Exclusives

Happy Wars *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Crackdown

Sunset overdrive *Gameplay* 2014

Project spark *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 PC

Scalebound

Super ultra mega double deluxe platinum extreme makeover Dead Rising 3 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo 5: Guardians

Killer instinct Season 2 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo Master Chief Edition *Gameplay* 2014

Phantom Dust

Forza Horizon 2 2014

Fable legends *Gameplay* Beta 2014

Ori and the Blind Forest *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

Inside *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

it was pretty even.



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

Tom3k on 10 June 2014

I think that both shows were very underwhelming...

MS from my point of view catered to existing XB gamers, doing nothing to actually draw those on fence, or those not even considering an XB.

SONY again instead of using the E3 as a platform to promote their internal studios, dropped the ball... And lack of Vita content was just sad...

Anyway it's pretty disappointing for both companies when for the best games that they've actually shown you don't even need a console...



jlmurph2 on 10 June 2014
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
jlmurph2 said:
TheBoneCollector said:
Sony had way more gameplay and exclusive focused:

Uncharted 4
Little big planet 3
The order
Blood borne (GAme of the show imo)
No mans sky  PC Indie
Grim Fandango PC
TLOU remaster
MAgicka 2 PC

All exclusive.

Exclusives

Happy Wars *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Crackdown

Sunset overdrive *Gameplay* 2014

Project spark *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 PC

Scalebound

Super ultra mega double deluxe platinum extreme makeover Dead Rising 3 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo 5: Guardians

Killer instinct Season 2 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo Master Chief Edition *Gameplay* 2014

Phantom Dust

Forza Horizon 2 2014

Fable legends *Gameplay* Beta 2014

Ori and the Blind Forest *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

Inside *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

it was pretty even.

How is that possibly even? Look again



Mohasus on 10 June 2014
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
jlmurph2 said:
TheBoneCollector said:
Sony had way more gameplay and exclusive focused:

Uncharted 4
Little big planet 3
The order
Blood borne (GAme of the show imo)
No mans sky
Grim Fandango
TLOU remaster
MAgicka 2

All exclusive.

Exclusives

Happy Wars *Gameplay Trailer* 2014

Crackdown

Sunset overdrive *Gameplay* 2014

Project spark *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 PC

Scalebound

Super ultra mega double deluxe platinum extreme makeover Dead Rising 3 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo 5: Guardians

Killer instinct Season 2 *Gameplay* 2014

Halo Master Chief Edition *Gameplay* 2014

Phantom Dust

Forza Horizon 2 2014

Fable legends *Gameplay* Beta 2014

Ori and the Blind Forest *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

Inside *Gameplay Trailer* 2014 Indie

it was pretty even.

Wtf why doesn't indie count? remove no man's sky then too.
Also magicka 2 (confirmed pc) and grim fandango (other platforms to be announced) aren't exclusives to playstation.

Anyway, MS won (IMO) simply because I watched the whole sony presentation and there wasn't a single game that made me think "I should buy a ps4". Hard to be excited about some cgs that I have no idea how they'll play.