Non Game mention: Automatic Disqualification

watch the stream here: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=184627&page=1#

There is no way you can make a 90 minute presentation of just gameplay.

Agreed, but there was still just a little too much CGI.

Sony 'cus Uncharted 4. /s

That scoring system isn't going to end well.

Lol, of course you can. MS couldn't. No one said the conference should be 90 minutes anyway. 

You're negative points for no "live" conference is BS. The digital event combined with live demos and 20+hrs of live feeds Nintendo is doing is equivalent or greater than a single hr long live event IMO.

You shouldn't force points on an opinion of yours.

Doesn't really matter though as MS conference was middle of the road, meh. Sony's will likely be the same with overall 3rd party content and a couple lack luster exclusives for this year. Like a big game or two mentioned for 2015 or onward.

Nintendo is only one with real significant games this year. Plus Zelda. Zelda trumps all anyways. +100.

I wonder if Sony manages half the points.

Seeing as neither Sony of MS showed off their flagship title - in much detail. I think Nintendo could take this one. Show gameplay footage of Zelda, and its practically theirs for the taking.

I'll take a quick crack at Nintendo if you'll come back to do Sony and finish this thing.

Open with Smash Bros: +5 points
Amiibo: assuming +5 points here
Yarn Yoshi: +15 points for all the new info & gameplay
Captain Toad: +25 points for new game with gameplay
Zelda: +20 points for new game with "gameplay"
Pokemon ORAS: +15(x2) points for gameplay reveal of two games
-5 points for kid in the trailer
-10(x2) points for being remakes
Bayonetta 2: +5 points for new footage
Bayonetta 1: -5 points for last-gen port
+ 10 points for being included with Bayonetta 2 at no extra cost
Hyrule Warriors: +15 points for lots of new gameplay
Kirby Rainbow Curse: +25 points for new game with gameplay
Xenoblade X: +5 points for new footage and actual title
Mario Maker: +25 points for new game with gameplay
Splatoon: +30 points for new exclusive IP
+5 points for with gameplay
Star Fox: +20 new game "announced" with no gameplay

As for the presentation --

-5 points for not being live
+5 points for Robot Chicken skits
-5 points for slight against Mother fans
+5 points for Reggie vs Iwata final destination no items
-5 points for Reggie talking too much
+5 points for Sakurai's glorious baritone
+5 points for focusing on developers instead of corporate salesmen
-5 points for too much time spent in a yarn shop

TOTAL: 210 points

Feel free to make adjustments wherever you see fit, the final say is yours of course. I had a little fun messing with points for no reason, you may feel like trimming the fat.