Why/why not?

That honor is for Super Mario 3D World. It's just platforming perfection, the Mario game I always wanted. Second place is for Pikmin 3, just because Iove Pikmin. On the other hand, since Mario Kart 8 runs at 59 FPS, it's actually one of the worst Wii U games. Do you get it?

Well I cant say Ive played all WiiU games but thats because they dont look good. So yes, yes it is the best WiiU game.

Yes. If only because of this gif

Time will tell, but so far I can't say I have enjoyed another Wii U (or Wii for that matter) title as much as I enjoy Mario Kart 8.

Depends on what kind of experience you are looking for I guess... In my case, I think so just based on the fact that I will play this way more than any other game on the wiiU so far

MK8 tied with SM3DW, but if i had to pick one it be SM3DW. MK8 is definitely>>>MKWii thats for sure. Tons of fun.

SSB for WiiU will obviously be #1 later :p

nope the Game hasnt got AA and its 59fps (+1fps copied).

I am disappointed that I cannot see these flaws on my 55inch tv.

Yeah. By far far far. 3D world was really great, and Pikmin 3 is amazing, but I can't put this down. It's freaking amazing.

What, with having this thread even existed... why, it's nothing short of magnificent in its glorious 720p!