Loz SS sooo low?!

this list is just...........SHOCKING.

Whoever compiled this list must have hit their head in the morning on their way to work.

#82. Halo 3 is just absurd.

It's sort of admiting they overrated it.

On the other hand you can bet we'll see games they originally underrated like Mirror's Edge or Nier.

I know it'll never happen but I wish they would put Uncharted 3 in the top 5 instead of 2. I've gone back and replayed them both numerous times (I keep very few games after beating/platinuming them and replay the ones I do keep at least once a year or so) and I just ALWAYS come away thinking 3 is the more fun game. Aside from smoother gameplay (and throwing back grenades is really nice) I just like the set-pieces and story better. There's no debate the final boss and villain are better in 3 and I would argue the story as well. I love 2 as well and it deserves top 15 but seriously 3 just had the misfortune of coming after 2 and being judged harshly based on being a sequel to a GREAT game. I feel like if people had played it first they would like it more.

Let me guess, The Last of Us is going to be 1? It may be one of the most overrated games ever. Right up there with Ocarina of Time.

Twilight Princess better be top 25.

There's debate, though. Villain and final boss is much better on the second game.

Do you really think that or are you just playing devil's advocate?

Well, IGN did give 3 a higher score. A perfect 10, in fact. Which means the game will miss the top 100 entirely :P

I really think that. The only thing missing in 2's final setpiece is Sullivan screaming at Nathan, which did happen on the third game.

huh...well ok that's the first time I've heard that.  I just prefer silent brooding and sinisterness over yelling villains.  To me Zoran was the weak point of 2 and by final boss I mean the tree section vs. the knife fight not the bridge collapse and protecting Elena and all that.