If you read my post, you'd know I said it felt rehashed from RE.  It just didn't add anything to the experience and enemies were always attacking anyway so it really didn't matter.

I'm guessing he probably played the game on medium

Eh, I couldn't possibly disagree more. It was easily one of my favourite games of all-time.

As for why it's getting a Remaster so soon; I'd say it's because A LOT of 360 owners grew tired of the lack of exclusives on the platform over the last four years (since Kinect became a thing) and jumped ship to Sony rather than going for an Xbox One. There'll be a good few people out there with shiny new PS4's that likely never had the chance to play TLOU the first time around, and as it became one of Sony's biggest games, it makes perfect sense to use it to bolster their summer lineup.

Sorry, after playing RE:4 it was a cake walk on hard. 

Ahn... we think it's good because we played the game and actually enjoyed it? Nobody has the patience to list all the things they like about it (and if you like it, you like A LOT of things about it). Saying it has a lot of GOTYs is just some kind of tl;dr. Why do you even care anyway, a lot of people liked (really like it, it's not just "the hype and the media WOW GREAT GAME I HAVE NO OPINION"), a few people don't like and that's it. We move on

It was released like 10 months ago.  It was already the high of production for PS3 it's already been selling well.   Especially for a Sony IP.

I think your problem is you went in with a whole bunch of preconceptions and that ruined the experinence for you. As a reviewer, that's one's job but as a gamer that's no way to play a game. TLOU reminded of me of the first dead space, with less gore. I completly immersed myself in the game, and thats the way its supposed to be played.

The Multiplayer which I didn't play might be a shooter, but the single player is barely qualified as a shooter. Guns are basically the quickest way to die when fighting clickers and infected. They are only ever good against human opponents and then even when conserving ammo I still never had more than like 20 shots. I would consider it more of a stealth game rather than a shooter, even the concept of running and gun makes absolutely no sense when talking about TLOU single player.

deal with it dude, its not like you need to play it again or something. Just wait until X arrives and someone makes a thread about how awesome it is, so other people can say is overrated (=

I feel sorry for people who are tricked by placebos.  This game is like 6 hours of gameplay and 2 hours of poorly written story wrapped with beatiful graphics.  I feel sorry for the people who spent 60 dollars on it.

If want to go that way, everything is somekind of a ''rehash'' from some previous game. So, this point is invalid!