I just had a 50 cc grand prix, staying out in front for all off them and got my first 3 star rating, so it could be true. Peach was second on all 4 races so I dont think the amount of points you win by effects the rating.
Maybe if you stay behind the leader and win all the races in the last few seconds (60 points and only 10 seconds or so in 1st place over 4 races) you should get a really bad rating like D or E if he is right and time spent in 1st is the only factor.
Wii - 3348 5602 9364 2110
Mario Kart - 0474 1321 9262











